{ "canonical_sha256_without_self": "a430dd26f512db7d64c933df65d9a97e6899028099333fe0a1212728f13126cd", "final_arrays": [ { "interventions": { "detached_learned": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 5.772373378931661e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.7709541968266947, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.26012631467157654, "last_quartile_mean": 7.487310404030723e-05, "mean": 7.085559036568156e-05, "normalized": [ 0.767456541889667, 0.8910969874796977, 0.7949526654342541, 0.7325741840266811, 0.943544133913626, 0.868390294625501, 0.8054913948148298, 0.7138323441642012, 0.5978064063949543, 0.5556378314836203, 0.5261854153191788, 0.505768953649729, 0.715108334510866, 0.6608161569684796, 0.612256437426044, 0.5785464585899268, 0.739960161627241, 0.6892568994732284, 0.697060043562065, 0.8113764458982461, 3.2405349047340315, 2.5249733605503017, 1.9894958890200054, 1.5842775624032772, 2.3150907133984013, 1.7369124395330813, 1.1174777605817472, 0.8878712764898554, 0.8457898829566253, 0.5666580094993431, 0.5093321459106411, 0.474467963670652 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.2405349047340315, "population_cv": 0.6532808754860918, "rest_mean": 5.3392646400930564e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.093225357948515, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00016515548777533694, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 5.437858635559678e-05, 6.313920312095433e-05, 5.632684042211622e-05, 5.1906976295867935e-05, 6.685537664452568e-05, 6.153030699351802e-05, 5.707356831408106e-05, 5.057901216787286e-05, 4.2357925849501044e-05, 3.9370046579279006e-05, 3.728317824425176e-05, 3.583655779948458e-05, 5.0669423217186704e-05, 4.682251892518252e-05, 4.338179132901132e-05, 4.099325087736361e-05, 5.2430314099183306e-05, 4.8837704525794834e-05, 4.9390600906917825e-05, 5.749055708292872e-05, 0.00022961001377552748, 0.00017890847811941057, 0.00014096690574660897, 0.00011225492198718712, 0.0001640371192479506, 0.00012306995631661266, 7.917954644653946e-05, 6.291064346441999e-05, 5.9928941482212394e-05, 4.015088779851794e-05, 3.608902989071794e-05, 3.36187076754868e-05 ] }, "learned": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 6.365272747643758e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.8123633197064085, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.2078076008289402, "last_quartile_mean": 7.835499945940683e-05, "mean": 7.614457786075945e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7854618236676242, 0.9130540849409994, 0.8147131127464502, 0.7522410092502885, 0.9690072688462938, 0.8892440039434748, 0.8242354060534288, 0.7396083689563772, 0.6126026690255093, 0.5670644008562938, 0.5359283946772616, 0.5145269561429746, 0.7290174418180176, 0.6731434248219464, 0.6214223500409742, 0.5883307730946398, 0.7535191463387267, 0.6934458909688136, 0.6978155985835179, 0.8168473226649812, 3.219066994145898, 2.5077095541323673, 1.973834673592298, 1.5759251613516239, 2.2647260999477155, 1.6880724220748888, 1.092454232265147, 0.8732751258075867, 0.8206258345435784, 0.5459870832104624, 0.48994656248557816, 0.45714680900426247 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.219066994145898, "population_cv": 0.6420341358971389, "rest_mean": 5.7697108584559625e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.04626897714722, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00017576091195223854, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 5.980865898891352e-05, 6.95241178618744e-05, 6.203598604770377e-05, 5.727907409891486e-05, 7.378464943030849e-05, 6.77111092954874e-05, 6.276105705183e-05, 5.631716703646816e-05, 4.664637162932195e-05, 4.3178879423066974e-05, 4.080804137629457e-05, 3.917843787348829e-05, 5.551072536036372e-05, 5.1256221922812983e-05, 4.731794251711108e-05, 4.47981983597856e-05, 5.737639730796218e-05, 5.2802144637098536e-05, 5.3134874178795144e-05, 6.219849456101656e-05, 0.0002451144973747432, 0.00019094848539680243, 0.00015029680798761547, 0.00011999815615126863, 0.0001724466128507629, 0.00012853756197728217, 8.318446634802967e-05, 6.64951658109203e-05, 6.248620775295421e-05, 4.157395596848801e-05, 3.7306774174794555e-05, 3.4809250792022794e-05 ] }, "uniform_value_backward": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 3.269887292844942e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 2.3568639793204684, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.8573319130483905, "last_quartile_mean": 1.3873890566173941e-05, "mean": 2.12624314031018e-05, "normalized": [ 1.6816001107908207, 1.968609461712434, 1.7075260440141944, 1.4905139409933708, 1.4972595154646264, 1.4034185225085787, 1.3238781474315933, 1.2301608589864579, 1.121553773570522, 1.0499501635664128, 1.001131281922829, 0.9633193641679035, 0.9560899219831485, 0.9203740514079343, 0.8930538331784411, 0.8703809179546808, 0.8841528402061924, 0.8558056863273277, 0.8550540488218812, 0.8483642525948266, 0.8350365031100208, 0.8178976965352276, 0.8078428125234317, 0.7969682791900239, 0.7797478584358322, 0.7532962238158083, 0.7097589943815636, 0.6713244476982704, 0.629948240254275, 0.5812766747709892, 0.5573943041371163, 0.5373112275432649 ], "peak_layer": 2, "peak_normalized": 1.968609461712434, "population_cv": 0.35388972104860866, "rest_mean": 2.2020403102268808e-05, "spike_contrast": 0.7797034481094922, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 1.716938422759995e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 2, 3, 1, 5, 4 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 0 }, "values": [ 3.5754907003138214e-05, 4.185742363915779e-05, 3.630615537986159e-05, 3.169195042573847e-05, 3.183537774020806e-05, 2.9840090064681135e-05, 2.8148868295829743e-05, 2.6156210878980346e-05, 2.3846960175433196e-05, 2.2324493329506367e-05, 2.128648520738352e-05, 2.048251189989969e-05, 2.0328796381363645e-05, 1.9569390133256093e-05, 1.8988495867233723e-05, 1.8506414562580176e-05, 1.8799239114741795e-05, 1.819650969991926e-05, 1.8180528059019707e-05, 1.8038286725641228e-05, 1.775490636646282e-05, 1.739049366733525e-05, 1.7176702385768294e-05, 1.6945483366725966e-05, 1.6579335351707414e-05, 1.6016909285099246e-05, 1.5091201930772513e-05, 1.4273990018409677e-05, 1.3394231245911215e-05, 1.2359355423541274e-05, 1.1851558156195097e-05, 1.1424543117755093e-05 ] } }, "position_element_rms": { "attention_branch_output": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 6.422064188882359e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6376814356469364, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.4499164375054873, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00010070959933727863, "mean": 8.629182207187114e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6940773401510585, 0.8062528427202595, 0.7180374505283312, 0.6647119372719499, 0.8588689882759897, 0.7941431696191276, 0.7473948010342778, 0.6703237246625169, 0.591781846497542, 0.522694550559361, 0.4893812082436792, 0.4670959071660659, 0.6619658672285874, 0.6164719403371215, 0.5787012511245688, 0.5393739243504363, 0.6707710740427385, 0.62668399370843, 0.6317390712162502, 0.6712190136492653, 3.138964807406113, 2.6795820619127526, 2.136435916928567, 1.6866743661161174, 2.264472697470994, 1.978410075097681, 1.4778942897678682, 0.9605324338748193, 1.022040338716437, 0.7239267286003249, 0.47869752189559756, 0.4306788598251707 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.138964807406113, "population_cv": 0.6905024564046187, "rest_mean": 6.421987658271703e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.1996375366532934, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00020548032771330326, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 5.989319834043272e-05, 6.957302684895694e-05, 6.196075992193073e-05, 5.7359204220119864e-05, 7.411336991935968e-05, 6.852806109236553e-05, 6.449405918829143e-05, 5.784345557913184e-05, 5.1065933803329244e-05, 4.5104265154805034e-05, 4.222959614708088e-05, 4.03065569116734e-05, 5.712224083254114e-05, 5.319648698787205e-05, 4.993718539481051e-05, 4.654355871025473e-05, 5.788205817225389e-05, 5.4077703680377454e-05, 5.4513915529241785e-05, 5.792071169707924e-05, 0.0002708669926505536, 0.00023122601851355284, 0.00018435694801155478, 0.00014554620429407805, 0.00019540547509677708, 0.0001707206101855263, 0.00012753019109368324, 8.288609387818724e-05, 8.81937230587937e-05, 6.246895645745099e-05, 4.1307681385660544e-05, 3.716406354214996e-05 ] }, "mlp_branch_output": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 6.365280069076107e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.8123684077728273, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.2078013375593398, "last_quartile_mean": 7.83545988269907e-05, "mean": 7.614439766712167e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7854660713099145, 0.9130496523819581, 0.8147298517264512, 0.752236196131495, 0.9689924576782674, 0.8892579571020611, 0.8242433765322099, 0.7396130336387524, 0.6125904066287632, 0.5670744382794471, 0.5359292329408729, 0.5145351492524995, 0.7290151059417195, 0.673146260009013, 0.621425875046763, 0.5883337897938153, 0.7535116607120764, 0.6934400787203782, 0.6978162466203766, 0.8168476312813977, 3.2190719364475022, 2.5076839554965473, 1.973830744692153, 1.575947332799018, 2.2647184639164535, 1.6880790923847124, 1.0924366554795215, 0.8732736568641918, 0.8206255787733402, 0.5459821164389519, 0.48994786526283923, 0.4571481297165359 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.2190719364475022, "population_cv": 0.642032487569562, "rest_mean": 5.76970003883751e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.0462648281411457, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0001757603429723531, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 5.9808840887853876e-05, 6.952361582079902e-05, 6.203711382113397e-05, 5.727857205783948e-05, 7.378334703389555e-05, 6.771201151423156e-05, 6.276151543715969e-05, 5.6317388953175396e-05, 4.664532752940431e-05, 4.3179541535209864e-05, 4.0808008634485304e-05, 3.917896901839413e-05, 5.551041613216512e-05, 5.125631651026197e-05, 4.731809895019978e-05, 4.479832205106504e-05, 5.7375691540073603e-05, 5.280157711240463e-05, 5.3134797781240195e-05, 6.219837086973712e-05, 0.00024511429364793, 0.00019094608433078974, 0.0001502961531514302, 0.00011999956041108817, 0.00017244562332052737, 0.00012853776570409536, 8.318293112097308e-05, 6.649489660048857e-05, 6.248604040592909e-05, 4.157347939326428e-05, 3.7306785088730976e-05, 3.480926898191683e-05 ] }, "post_attention_state": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 6.422088154067751e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.637682021407296, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.44991551892756126, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00010070988264487823, "mean": 8.629204910448607e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6940783808537224, 0.8062729813904731, 0.7180303336815479, 0.6647219507645815, 0.8588589713696609, 0.794136864353616, 0.7473889560340541, 0.6703283692089702, 0.5917748510321142, 0.5226947352403994, 0.4893764215021349, 0.4670989784552037, 0.661952700545094, 0.6164859593679979, 0.5786990118719374, 0.539368710966703, 0.6707742418503443, 0.6266861813765591, 0.6317438172781369, 0.6712283354793382, 3.1389231589965445, 2.679577878793134, 2.1364533990925567, 1.686690164787602, 2.264487313238182, 1.9784244316759128, 1.477878596963198, 0.9605191983702851, 1.022047261980904, 0.7239260887312458, 0.4786954192739982, 0.4306763354738471 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.1389231589965445, "population_cv": 0.690500620274875, "rest_mean": 6.42200389443638e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.1996384204494492, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0002054809039691463, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 5.98934457229916e-05, 6.957494770176709e-05, 6.196030881255865e-05, 5.736021921620704e-05, 7.411270053125918e-05, 6.852769729448482e-05, 6.449372449424118e-05, 5.784400855191052e-05, 5.106546450406313e-05, 4.51043997600209e-05, 4.2229294194839895e-05, 4.030692798551172e-05, 5.7121254940284416e-05, 5.319783667800948e-05, 4.993712354917079e-05, 4.654323129216209e-05, 5.788248381577432e-05, 5.40780347364489e-05, 5.451446850202046e-05, 5.7921668485505506e-05, 0.00027086411137133837, 0.00023122626589611173, 0.00018435894162394106, 0.00014554795052390546, 0.00019540725043043494, 0.0001707222982076928, 0.00012752917245961726, 8.288516983157024e-05, 8.819455251796171e-05, 6.24690655968152e-05, 4.13076086260844e-05, 3.716394348884933e-05 ] }, "post_mlp_state": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 6.365272747643758e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.8123633197064085, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.2078076008289402, "last_quartile_mean": 7.835499945940683e-05, "mean": 7.614457786075945e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7854618236676242, 0.9130540849409994, 0.8147131127464502, 0.7522410092502885, 0.9690072688462938, 0.8892440039434748, 0.8242354060534288, 0.7396083689563772, 0.6126026690255093, 0.5670644008562938, 0.5359283946772616, 0.5145269561429746, 0.7290174418180176, 0.6731434248219464, 0.6214223500409742, 0.5883307730946398, 0.7535191463387267, 0.6934458909688136, 0.6978155985835179, 0.8168473226649812, 3.219066994145898, 2.5077095541323673, 1.973834673592298, 1.5759251613516239, 2.2647260999477155, 1.6880724220748888, 1.092454232265147, 0.8732751258075867, 0.8206258345435784, 0.5459870832104624, 0.48994656248557816, 0.45714680900426247 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.219066994145898, "population_cv": 0.6420341358971389, "rest_mean": 5.7697108584559625e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.04626897714722, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00017576091195223854, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 5.980865898891352e-05, 6.95241178618744e-05, 6.203598604770377e-05, 5.727907409891486e-05, 7.378464943030849e-05, 6.77111092954874e-05, 6.276105705183e-05, 5.631716703646816e-05, 4.664637162932195e-05, 4.3178879423066974e-05, 4.080804137629457e-05, 3.917843787348829e-05, 5.551072536036372e-05, 5.1256221922812983e-05, 4.731794251711108e-05, 4.47981983597856e-05, 5.737639730796218e-05, 5.2802144637098536e-05, 5.3134874178795144e-05, 6.219849456101656e-05, 0.0002451144973747432, 0.00019094848539680243, 0.00015029680798761547, 0.00011999815615126863, 0.0001724466128507629, 0.00012853756197728217, 8.318446634802967e-05, 6.64951658109203e-05, 6.248620775295421e-05, 4.157395596848801e-05, 3.7306774174794555e-05, 3.4809250792022794e-05 ] }, "pre_attention_input": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 3.944479362871789e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.1135282861542686, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.1075336103151947, "last_quartile_mean": 3.54232524841791e-05, "mean": 5.533300526394669e-05, "normalized": [ 0.5280207224829799, 0.8999098868607942, 0.6284748654319019, 0.5778568458898549, 0.34988006202074273, 0.7764713506345448, 0.9190909808587969, 1.023190827540606, 0.6226417920568781, 0.5519145939388094, 0.4568960180345979, 0.4213932325876586, 0.4074494455716704, 0.7465319443901276, 0.6474109861274324, 0.5764712279753077, 0.7979703549327781, 1.2369697451324837, 1.2324489817728508, 1.5808985864286207, 2.5860289117498976, 4.232714993086349, 2.835646318943954, 2.2422528664695807, 1.1646676435019565, 1.2175941057769888, 0.783401544111113, 0.5289102464485725, 0.46735876466607296, 0.2966943922188728, 0.3266155865457417, 0.3362221758114643 ], "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 4.232714993086349, "population_cv": 0.8496980089222349, "rest_mean": 3.881239232820614e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.7241794809927478, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00014454431511694564, "top_five_layers": [ 22, 23, 21, 24, 20 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 2.921697341662366e-05, 4.9794718506745994e-05, 3.477540303720161e-05, 3.197455589543097e-05, 1.9359915313543752e-05, 4.296449333196506e-05, 5.085606608190574e-05, 5.661622344632633e-05, 3.4452641557436436e-05, 3.053909313166514e-05, 2.5281429770984687e-05, 2.3316953956964426e-05, 2.2545402316609398e-05, 4.1307856008643284e-05, 3.582319550332613e-05, 3.189788549207151e-05, 4.415409784996882e-05, 6.844525341875851e-05, 6.819510599598289e-05, 8.747586980462074e-05, 0.0001430927513865754, 0.00023420884099323303, 0.00015690483269281685, 0.00012407058966346085, 6.444456084864214e-05, 6.737314106430858e-05, 4.3347961764084175e-05, 2.9266193450894207e-05, 2.5860364985419437e-05, 1.641699236643035e-05, 1.807262196962256e-05, 1.8604183424031362e-05 ] }, "pre_mlp_input": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 1.8878105947806034e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.1437388462831867, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 1.939757193388504, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00013133614493199275, "mean": 7.144442986373178e-05, "normalized": [ 0.543944422065902, 0.20498362677674017, 0.14117605251679072, 0.2675823635170904, 0.19429426405696296, 0.15941273479469137, 0.21634544427316113, 0.386139638870723, 0.42865458135412043, 0.3129364237141443, 0.2788876084512782, 0.2815826978190512, 0.3736543391719335, 0.3909795972451435, 0.4389936626557141, 0.44232523153890874, 0.3688366584716598, 0.45947150441297413, 0.42734480687548726, 0.5800824758005463, 2.6187902433353907, 2.987231504916195, 2.580721746390286, 2.2092452217225382, 2.879951595578818, 2.8406783220158585, 2.397028447242086, 1.5906421267626043, 1.8247593500794728, 1.4018234858691145, 0.9198949147470885, 0.8516049069575247 ], "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 2.987231504916195, "population_cv": 0.9601858610516129, "rest_mean": 4.954554700547036e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.828767846228416, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00018969839729834347, "top_five_layers": [ 22, 25, 26, 21, 23 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 3.886179911205545e-05, 1.4644938346464187e-05, 1.008624258247437e-05, 1.911726940306835e-05, 1.3881242921343073e-05, 1.1389151950425003e-05, 1.5456676919711754e-05, 2.7587526346906088e-05, 3.062498217332177e-05, 2.2357564375852235e-05, 1.9924966181861237e-05, 2.0117515305173583e-05, 2.6695521228248253e-05, 2.7933314413530752e-05, 3.13636519422289e-05, 3.160167398164049e-05, 2.6351324777351692e-05, 3.282667967141606e-05, 3.0531406082445756e-05, 4.144366175751202e-05, 0.00018709797586780041, 0.00021342105173971504, 0.0001843781938077882, 0.00015783826529514045, 0.0002057564997812733, 0.0002029506431426853, 0.00017125433078035712, 0.00011364251986378804, 0.00013036889140494168, 0.00010015247971750796, 6.572136771865189e-05, 6.08424270467367e-05 ] } }, "post_mlp_reductions": { "batch_mean_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 1.5986864127626177e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.8170274391577745, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.20208259942567244, "last_quartile_mean": 1.956710798367567e-05, "mean": 1.9039307829871177e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7853167979867789, 0.9097665173048055, 0.808777694116954, 0.752402497635975, 0.9858540561935626, 0.9044938358034963, 0.8288447236919866, 0.7419578801196516, 0.6090850929460484, 0.5628647453138417, 0.5328979550345672, 0.5131403750850531, 0.7265824660927316, 0.6757007408890954, 0.6225826951824261, 0.5898791530514104, 0.7532772493405897, 0.6927950381940383, 0.6897848547806317, 0.8094505726944553, 3.2076147584918284, 2.5002121502474965, 1.982484105644761, 1.5924612114390058, 2.273889158865966, 1.6940625327896233, 1.0968336406315982, 0.8719471681044353, 0.815653609383569, 0.5388945327422838, 0.4819664542042268, 0.448525735997107 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.2076147584918284, "population_cv": 0.6428608089466793, "rest_mean": 1.4415815443229534e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.052631111367605, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 4.400616671773605e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 1.4951888260839041e-05, 1.7321324776276015e-05, 1.5398567484226078e-05, 1.4325222764455248e-05, 1.8769978851196356e-05, 1.7220936570083722e-05, 1.5780629837536253e-05, 1.4126364476396702e-05, 1.1596558579185512e-05, 1.0716555152612273e-05, 1.0146008207811974e-05, 9.769837561179884e-06, 1.3833627235726453e-05, 1.286487440665951e-05, 1.1853543583129067e-05, 1.1230890777369495e-05, 1.4341877431434114e-05, 1.3190337995183654e-05, 1.3133026186551433e-05, 1.541137862659525e-05, 6.107076478656381e-05, 4.760230876854621e-05, 3.7745125155197456e-05, 3.03193592117168e-05, 4.329327566665597e-05, 3.225377804483287e-05, 2.0882953322143294e-05, 1.6601270544924773e-05, 1.5529480151599273e-05, 1.0260178896714933e-05, 9.176307685265783e-06, 8.539619557268452e-06 ] }, "element_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 6.365272747643758e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.8123633197064085, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.2078076008289402, "last_quartile_mean": 7.835499945940683e-05, "mean": 7.614457786075945e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7854618236676242, 0.9130540849409994, 0.8147131127464502, 0.7522410092502885, 0.9690072688462938, 0.8892440039434748, 0.8242354060534288, 0.7396083689563772, 0.6126026690255093, 0.5670644008562938, 0.5359283946772616, 0.5145269561429746, 0.7290174418180176, 0.6731434248219464, 0.6214223500409742, 0.5883307730946398, 0.7535191463387267, 0.6934458909688136, 0.6978155985835179, 0.8168473226649812, 3.219066994145898, 2.5077095541323673, 1.973834673592298, 1.5759251613516239, 2.2647260999477155, 1.6880724220748888, 1.092454232265147, 0.8732751258075867, 0.8206258345435784, 0.5459870832104624, 0.48994656248557816, 0.45714680900426247 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.219066994145898, "population_cv": 0.6420341358971389, "rest_mean": 5.7697108584559625e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.04626897714722, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00017576091195223854, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 5.980865898891352e-05, 6.95241178618744e-05, 6.203598604770377e-05, 5.727907409891486e-05, 7.378464943030849e-05, 6.77111092954874e-05, 6.276105705183e-05, 5.631716703646816e-05, 4.664637162932195e-05, 4.3178879423066974e-05, 4.080804137629457e-05, 3.917843787348829e-05, 5.551072536036372e-05, 5.1256221922812983e-05, 4.731794251711108e-05, 4.47981983597856e-05, 5.737639730796218e-05, 5.2802144637098536e-05, 5.3134874178795144e-05, 6.219849456101656e-05, 0.0002451144973747432, 0.00019094848539680243, 0.00015029680798761547, 0.00011999815615126863, 0.0001724466128507629, 0.00012853756197728217, 8.318446634802967e-05, 6.64951658109203e-05, 6.248620775295421e-05, 4.157395596848801e-05, 3.7306774174794555e-05, 3.4809250792022794e-05 ] }, "global_l2": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 0.05644787335768342, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.8123632868395458, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.2078076412872703, "last_quartile_mean": 0.06948599754832685, "mean": 0.06752577290171757, "normalized": [ 0.7854618348329956, 0.9130540359301327, 0.8147131249195937, 0.7522410113175043, 0.9690071730110875, 0.88924395208314, 0.8242353599678512, 0.7396083806676593, 0.6126026750590019, 0.5670643980854334, 0.5359283892166958, 0.5145269586503932, 0.7290174229589911, 0.6731434525628229, 0.6214223402600404, 0.5883307763560162, 0.7535191533057549, 0.6934459281737582, 0.6978155981634587, 0.8168473704719704, 3.2190670201887848, 2.507709505453073, 1.9738347607250095, 1.5759251284181852, 2.264726151347608, 1.68807248858185, 1.0924542395938426, 0.8732750663142743, 0.820625855657368, 0.5459870819951741, 0.48994655813463567, 0.45714680759589343 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.2190670201887848, "population_cv": 0.6420341436220799, "rest_mean": 0.05116637251167386, "spike_contrast": 3.0462690113979045, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.15586653500795364, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 0.05303891748189926, 0.06165467947721481, 0.05501413345336914, 0.05079565569758415, 0.06543295830488205, 0.060046885162591934, 0.05565712973475456, 0.04994262754917145, 0.041366469115018845, 0.038291461765766144, 0.03618897870182991, 0.03474383056163788, 0.04922746494412422, 0.04545453190803528, 0.041962023824453354, 0.03972749039530754, 0.05088196322321892, 0.04682547226548195, 0.04712053760886192, 0.05515825003385544, 0.21736998856067657, 0.1693350225687027, 0.13328471779823303, 0.10641556233167648, 0.15292738378047943, 0.11398839950561523, 0.07376881688833237, 0.058968573808670044, 0.055413395166397095, 0.036868199706077576, 0.033084020018577576, 0.030869191512465477 ] }, "token_mean_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 2.579253447265728e-06, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.47590496457778414, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.7425370989326324, "last_quartile_mean": 5.419681741614113e-06, "mean": 4.2137082871818166e-06, "normalized": [ 0.6771144196047112, 0.6338426021784607, 0.6121020910961615, 0.6258737201152189, 0.6050362914422536, 0.5852204423685657, 0.5784631886764509, 0.5792281322851218, 0.4697078599262646, 0.4522117174548025, 0.44580914592548354, 0.4558904724294877, 0.5773213311917524, 0.5667240346830847, 0.5644321177223985, 0.5681434108598962, 0.6503548834184826, 0.6631947770191623, 0.6837887360559592, 0.7582966501774209, 3.020973835679826, 2.627473806530212, 2.3058644468737186, 2.00331262981993, 2.819406877957528, 2.1402761714678284, 1.4825745701937771, 1.1227288221975413, 0.9855094000056028, 0.6429466506282437, 0.5709200007532207, 0.5252567632614316 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.020973835679826, "population_cv": 0.7577358346351384, "rest_mean": 2.999999306094078e-06, "spike_contrast": 3.589246425218318, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 1.0767736785055605e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 25, 22, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 2.8531626412586775e-06, 2.670827825568267e-06, 2.5792196538532153e-06, 2.6372492811788106e-06, 2.5494464352959767e-06, 2.465948227836634e-06, 2.43747513195558e-06, 2.440698381178663e-06, 1.979211901925737e-06, 1.9054882614000235e-06, 1.8785096926876577e-06, 1.920989461723366e-06, 2.4326636776095256e-06, 2.3880097614892293e-06, 2.3783522919984534e-06, 2.393990598648088e-06, 2.7404057618696243e-06, 2.7945093279413413e-06, 2.8812862638005754e-06, 3.1952408789948095e-06, 1.2729502486763522e-05, 1.1071408152929507e-05, 9.716240128909703e-06, 8.441375030088238e-06, 1.1880158126587048e-05, 9.018499440571759e-06, 6.247136752790539e-06, 4.7308517423516605e-06, 4.152649125899188e-06, 2.709189629968023e-06, 2.405690338491695e-06, 2.2132787762529915e-06 ] }, "token_rms_mean": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.826905797017389e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.9723593605402814, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.028029830358518852, "last_quartile_mean": 4.964117169947713e-05, "mean": 5.395593586854375e-05, "normalized": [ 0.8546740011831107, 0.9667023865336807, 0.8780594173977533, 0.8215201862718362, 1.028762848378348, 0.9492707323927138, 0.8750383055629682, 0.7827836490446655, 0.6672270484578459, 0.6202534690629704, 0.5854228619045188, 0.5620710233383177, 0.781592991024926, 0.7155185842665527, 0.6597031604820425, 0.621567177701999, 0.8222052916650392, 0.7616961441483728, 0.7641199379358804, 0.8753280307745216, 3.236716477578425, 2.479496544122304, 1.8830004075567146, 1.4470156791415152, 2.05665793704697, 1.5065644924277526, 1.0009572516438536, 0.8155596816984735, 0.6595753226879756, 0.4759799891964506, 0.4318790517932509, 0.413079917578251 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.236716477578425, "population_cv": 0.6107674157639074, "rest_mean": 4.176012171902349e-05, "spike_contrast": 2.869084843241085, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00011981333227595314, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 4.61147355963476e-05, 5.2159331971779466e-05, 4.737651761388406e-05, 4.4325890485197306e-05, 5.550786227104254e-05, 5.121879075886682e-05, 4.72135106974747e-05, 4.2235824366798624e-05, 3.6000859836349264e-05, 3.3466356399003416e-05, 3.158703839289956e-05, 3.0327068088809028e-05, 4.217158129904419e-05, 3.860647484543733e-05, 3.559490141924471e-05, 3.353723877808079e-05, 4.4362855987856165e-05, 4.1098028304986656e-05, 4.122880636714399e-05, 4.7229143092408776e-05, 0.00017464006668888032, 0.00013378355652093887, 0.00010159904923057184, 7.807508518453687e-05, 0.00011096890375483781, 8.128809713525698e-05, 5.400758527684957e-05, 4.4004285882692784e-05, 3.558800381142646e-05, 2.5681945771793835e-05, 2.330243842152413e-05, 2.228811354143545e-05 ] }, "token_rms_median": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 3.626825309765991e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.1971952602722011, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.17998153797771219, "last_quartile_mean": 3.0294350722215313e-05, "mean": 3.794959516767449e-05, "normalized": [ 0.9342317076920968, 1.032527492584725, 0.9483990781630639, 0.8885231558783968, 1.1008949985426397, 1.0148066560537, 0.9027782413985963, 0.8234017777861798, 0.7333936750261243, 0.6823073758552121, 0.6464481216407498, 0.616777331910669, 0.8501710687237772, 0.7702178906455867, 0.7042577074377577, 0.660638930723233, 0.914060026408416, 0.847914539167618, 0.8394293783449699, 0.9442746494437388, 3.300220154812763, 2.4489522165880904, 1.7640184700183157, 1.245126339879113, 1.7643693302152461, 1.271277790934411, 0.9095623054467832, 0.780451313056054, 0.5159478762516835, 0.40747033934370974, 0.37633772798986104, 0.36081233203671814 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.300220154812763, "population_cv": 0.5858778602410362, "rest_mean": 3.018723526582579e-05, "spike_contrast": 2.6456990159702416, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 7.986633863765746e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 3.5453715099720284e-05, 3.9184000343084335e-05, 3.599136107368395e-05, 3.371909406268969e-05, 4.1778519516810775e-05, 3.85115017706994e-05, 3.4260068787261844e-05, 3.124776412732899e-05, 2.783199306577444e-05, 2.5893288693623617e-05, 2.453244451317005e-05, 2.3406450054608285e-05, 3.226364788133651e-05, 2.9229457140900195e-05, 2.6726294890977442e-05, 2.5070979972952046e-05, 3.468820796115324e-05, 3.217801349819638e-05, 3.185600508004427e-05, 3.5834840673487633e-05, 0.00012524201883934438, 9.293674520449713e-05, 6.694378680549562e-05, 4.725204053102061e-05, 6.695710180792958e-05, 4.8244477511616424e-05, 3.451752127148211e-05, 2.9617811378557235e-05, 1.95800130313728e-05, 1.546333442092873e-05, 1.4281864423537627e-05, 1.3692681932298001e-05 ] }, "token_rms_p95": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 0.00012846494701079791, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.7741545804954827, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.25598370893064326, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00016594224234722788, "mean": 0.000157460202672155, "normalized": [ 0.7615886502877881, 0.869859991005712, 0.7823534284439785, 0.735201115807512, 0.9596786286759813, 0.8813992955944876, 0.8128285893567467, 0.7239431731448671, 0.5977864740547744, 0.5606030792342883, 0.5318673348078621, 0.5130567490014816, 0.6987134321316841, 0.6407269063222457, 0.6075335461477536, 0.5704889146486948, 0.7180428901779269, 0.6784140170824181, 0.6819219612414157, 0.7908928021790416, 3.2176296651190497, 2.545498211708922, 2.0288816729118655, 1.6601468184271124, 2.321862751456626, 1.7738386620365922, 1.1711907122839438, 0.9284857615000071, 0.7896970255450443, 0.5236030848875767, 0.47341239614817127, 0.4488522586284289 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.2176296651190497, "population_cv": 0.6625973254291921, "rest_mean": 0.0001179550758765631, "spike_contrast": 3.143466990402101, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00037078788736835124, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 0.00011991990322712809, 0.00013696833048015833, 0.00012318952940404415, 0.00011576491669984534, 0.0001511111913714558, 0.00013878531171940267, 0.00012798815441783518, 0.00011399223876651376, 9.412757935933769e-05, 8.82726744748652e-05, 8.374793833354488e-05, 8.078601968009025e-05, 0.000110019558633212, 0.00010088898852700368, 9.566235530655831e-05, 8.982930012280121e-05, 0.0001130631790147163, 0.00010682320862542838, 0.00010737557022366673, 0.00012453414092306048, 0.0005066486191935837, 0.00040081466431729496, 0.00031946811941452324, 0.0002614070544950664, 0.0003656009794212878, 0.00027930899523198605, 0.00018441592692397535, 0.00014619955618400127, 0.00012434585369192064, 8.24466478661634e-05, 7.454361184500158e-05, 7.067636761348695e-05 ] } }, "seed": 2026073001 }, { "interventions": { "detached_learned": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.0602767057862366e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6220527400735582, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.47473039872247574, "last_quartile_mean": 6.52722260383598e-05, "mean": 6.584079096683126e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6772375898692375, 0.7419156446131505, 0.6265276809050203, 0.5983548462080928, 0.6909826192767372, 0.5826528795658069, 0.521809962087311, 0.49396705008933894, 0.6208428547650034, 0.583552196572707, 0.5417821373953783, 0.5073870191655783, 0.43782941267698894, 0.4086714236070873, 0.40807611508949443, 0.4979465665227966, 1.2379953934660572, 1.244289507430791, 1.1312943811704865, 1.027048864560996, 3.6326329119144347, 2.8432062989929086, 2.2290691465672023, 1.784011106006968, 1.8683393699616757, 1.5302817088353375, 1.1091498325862283, 0.8793222326330687, 0.8937044532253541, 0.6693159640810682, 0.5098515212827301, 0.47095130887496306 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6326329119144347, "population_cv": 0.7406534740263053, "rest_mean": 4.7899763524549565e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.3971428496041334, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00016272233915515244, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.458985858946107e-05, 4.884831287199631e-05, 4.1251078073401004e-05, 3.93961563531775e-05, 4.549484219751321e-05, 3.83623264497146e-05, 3.435638063820079e-05, 3.252318128943443e-05, 4.087678462383337e-05, 3.8421538192778826e-05, 3.567136445781216e-05, 3.340676266816445e-05, 2.882703483919613e-05, 2.6907249775831588e-05, 2.686805419216398e-05, 3.278519579907879e-05, 8.15105959190987e-05, 8.192500536097214e-05, 7.448531687259674e-05, 6.762170960428193e-05, 0.00023917542421258986, 0.00018719895160757005, 0.00014676367572974414, 0.00011746070231311023, 0.00012301294191274792, 0.0001007549581117928, 7.302730227820575e-05, 5.789527131128125e-05, 5.8842208090936765e-05, 4.4068292481824756e-05, 3.356902743689716e-05, 3.100780668319203e-05 ] }, "learned": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.398412329464918e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6452634668607965, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.43809656983670076, "last_quartile_mean": 6.816459563196986e-05, "mean": 7.03343731061068e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6809932372926891, 0.7475632825133391, 0.6323153694166137, 0.6077851857944574, 0.7056447138179579, 0.5942446047107566, 0.530223262177042, 0.504089839823597, 0.6368974480554273, 0.5978888745536934, 0.5559539610577222, 0.5232972563751404, 0.4434509399790644, 0.41411238498840724, 0.4174418363858031, 0.5192489699581264, 1.2557404086895352, 1.2676084925356499, 1.1574347089891701, 1.060138766241709, 3.6189242296270336, 2.81239769967395, 2.2018329150221976, 1.7615672973682381, 1.8179181698124194, 1.4871187506667403, 1.086854135909831, 0.872703317202576, 0.8717669049561169, 0.6523365087620864, 0.4999226915339381, 0.46458383610897114 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6189242296270336, "population_cv": 0.7299683279122143, "rest_mean": 5.15456125598306e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.3328477735441013, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00017179368005599828, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.789723243447952e-05, 5.257939483271912e-05, 4.447350511327386e-05, 4.274819002603181e-05, 4.96310785820242e-05, 4.17958217440173e-05, 3.729292075149715e-05, 3.545484287315048e-05, 4.479578274185769e-05, 4.205213917884976e-05, 3.91026733268518e-05, 3.680578447529115e-05, 3.1189843866741285e-05, 2.9126334993634373e-05, 2.9360509870457463e-05, 3.65210507879965e-05, 8.83217144291848e-05, 8.915644866647199e-05, 8.140744466800243e-05, 7.45641955290921e-05, 0.0002545347670093179, 0.0001978082291316241, 0.000154864537762478, 0.00012389873154461384, 0.00012786213483195752, 0.00010459556506248191, 7.644320430699736e-05, 6.138104072306305e-05, 6.131517875473946e-05, 4.588167939800769e-05, 3.516174911055714e-05, 3.2676212867954746e-05 ] }, "uniform_value_backward": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 3.093152440669655e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 2.2774685844866087, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.8230645561980515, "last_quartile_mean": 1.3581537245954678e-05, "mean": 2.01113496416383e-05, "normalized": [ 1.8305028390484899, 2.063895445405066, 1.6144389462797186, 1.4292254312672816, 1.5742789705777873, 1.395222470726611, 1.2383859090556808, 1.15815685579556, 1.0870603073810894, 1.0303295548521039, 0.9686496018996943, 0.9150613022126579, 0.8858369611012855, 0.866010221809998, 0.8620422691094124, 0.8950413704487017, 0.898565866832108, 0.8961986259205167, 0.8726168436106015, 0.8416436403028231, 0.8273619591175169, 0.8203659676564082, 0.8150936944275661, 0.8114785712381606, 0.790107287070579, 0.7656015997474095, 0.7288914121037795, 0.6928588452491169, 0.6522528807444096, 0.6198966689630461, 0.586304513764539, 0.566623166280281 ], "peak_layer": 2, "peak_normalized": 2.063895445405066, "population_cv": 0.3585699713300157, "rest_mean": 2.0808239578737238e-05, "spike_contrast": 0.7856572354159773, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 1.634814398130402e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 2, 1, 3, 5, 4 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 0 }, "values": [ 3.6813882616115734e-05, 4.1507722926326096e-05, 3.246854612370953e-05, 2.874365236493759e-05, 3.166087481076829e-05, 2.805980693665333e-05, 2.4905612008296885e-05, 2.329209746676497e-05, 2.186224992328789e-05, 2.072131792374421e-05, 1.9480850824038498e-05, 1.8403117792331614e-05, 1.7815376850194298e-05, 1.7416634364053607e-05, 1.7336833479930647e-05, 1.800048994482495e-05, 1.8071372323902324e-05, 1.8023763914243318e-05, 1.7549502445035614e-05, 1.6926589523791336e-05, 1.6639365640003234e-05, 1.6498666809638962e-05, 1.6392634279327467e-05, 1.631992927286774e-05, 1.5890123904682696e-05, 1.539728145871777e-05, 1.4658990039606579e-05, 1.3934326489106752e-05, 1.3117685739416629e-05, 1.246695865120273e-05, 1.1791375072789378e-05, 1.1395556612114888e-05 ] } }, "position_element_rms": { "attention_branch_output": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.418448133947095e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.515514370401758, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.662590099285622, "last_quartile_mean": 8.570950467401417e-05, "mean": 8.019432914352365e-05, "normalized": [ 0.5977618675800617, 0.6560769396425044, 0.5549086183167843, 0.5332641078022274, 0.6187504975834317, 0.5235180355140238, 0.4739614950807707, 0.44949966520899015, 0.5901273331445138, 0.5434806557289369, 0.5105162863240122, 0.47519844997761185, 0.40525254510695746, 0.3803726356397213, 0.3632907544081655, 0.4413534187685878, 1.1120243122062796, 1.1101422281940985, 1.048076642833664, 0.9240879167666287, 3.7925106998539326, 3.0713745688935163, 2.3834694147362985, 1.8907998104142179, 1.7924928574135153, 1.575834720390749, 1.2856009256033192, 0.946613406637061, 1.179458790809137, 0.7622280566154953, 0.5700461300235112, 0.43790621278127495 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.7925106998539326, "population_cv": 0.799556889668146, "rest_mean": 5.663903492084636e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.6616605179769537, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00020739291794598104, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.793711195816286e-05, 5.261365004116669e-05, 4.450052438187413e-05, 4.27647573815193e-05, 4.9620281060924754e-05, 4.1983177652582526e-05, 3.800902413786389e-05, 3.604732410167344e-05, 4.7324865590780973e-05, 4.358406658866443e-05, 4.09405110985972e-05, 3.810822090599686e-05, 3.249895598855801e-05, 3.0503728339681402e-05, 2.913385833380744e-05, 3.539404133334756e-05, 8.917804370867088e-05, 8.902711124392226e-05, 8.404980326304212e-05, 7.410661055473611e-05, 0.0003041378513444215, 0.0002463068231008947, 0.00019114073074888438, 0.0001516314223408699, 0.00014374776219483465, 0.00012637300824280828, 0.00010309790377505124, 7.591302710352466e-05, 9.458590648137033e-05, 6.11263676546514e-05, 4.5714466978097335e-05, 3.511759496177547e-05 ] }, "mlp_branch_output": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.3983808154735016e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6452579224313538, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.43810516237842645, "last_quartile_mean": 6.816469294790295e-05, "mean": 7.033422900803998e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6809924600708206, 0.7475303658027369, 0.6323190441913445, 0.6077859654839745, 0.7056348319250383, 0.5942536325242065, 0.530225745030374, 0.5040918553425093, 0.6368908391102093, 0.5978963063844708, 0.5559498242106791, 0.5233025181432952, 0.44344812436490716, 0.41411157823288425, 0.41744328645242573, 0.5192458958427938, 1.2557243607052013, 1.2676253654309775, 1.1574430802993265, 1.060137110625566, 3.6189237818679025, 2.8123811167698722, 2.2018107363871295, 1.7616009064115667, 1.8179427908533603, 1.4871270732826793, 1.0868453970932423, 0.8727044844737096, 0.8717769668640218, 0.6523346900704022, 0.4999162674775265, 0.4645835982748448 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6189237818679025, "population_cv": 0.7299683580686596, "rest_mean": 5.154545740677147e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.3328561680843984, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00017179359565488994, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.789707963936962e-05, 5.2576971938833594e-05, 4.4473672460298985e-05, 4.274815728422254e-05, 4.963028186466545e-05, 4.1796371078817174e-05, 3.729301897692494e-05, 3.545491199474782e-05, 4.479522613110021e-05, 4.205257573630661e-05, 3.910230225301348e-05, 3.680607915157452e-05, 3.1189581932267174e-05, 2.9126218578312546e-05, 2.9360551707213745e-05, 3.6520759749691933e-05, 8.832040475681424e-05, 8.915745274862275e-05, 8.140786667354405e-05, 7.456392631866038e-05, 0.0002545342140365392, 0.00019780665752477944, 0.00015486266056541353, 0.00012390084157232195, 0.00012786360457539558, 0.00010459593613632023, 7.644243305549026e-05, 6.138099706731737e-05, 6.13157608313486e-05, 4.588145748130046e-05, 3.516122524160892e-05, 3.267612919444218e-05 ] }, "post_attention_state": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.4184340367792174e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.5155127283755759, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.6625932845097232, "last_quartile_mean": 8.570950421926682e-05, "mean": 8.019429117211985e-05, "normalized": [ 0.5977553912963086, 0.6560764337279869, 0.5549115575710053, 0.5332632715493767, 0.618731238431461, 0.5235220032899371, 0.4739610390296197, 0.44950831585208795, 0.5901295178770004, 0.5434863568103182, 0.5105118554999238, 0.4751981306058326, 0.4052536442822589, 0.3803760366271764, 0.36329074496540736, 0.44135367311072854, 1.112029465926781, 1.1101484697729092, 1.04807895367264, 0.9240971550402413, 3.7925041485004933, 3.0713698535863756, 2.383447135178006, 1.890810504439103, 1.7925006015588865, 1.5758247605004587, 1.2855904653729862, 0.9466104071448787, 1.1794713255182339, 0.7622315023149855, 0.5700532953493974, 0.43790274559719394 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.7925041485004933, "population_cv": 0.7995548542275265, "rest_mean": 5.6639052976000435e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.6616533387138865, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0002073925774311647, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.79365698993206e-05, 5.2613584557548165e-05, 4.450073902262375e-05, 4.276467007002793e-05, 4.96187130920589e-05, 4.198347596684471e-05, 3.800896956818178e-05, 3.604800076573156e-05, 4.732501838589087e-05, 4.358450314612128e-05, 4.094013638678007e-05, 3.8108177250251174e-05, 3.249902874813415e-05, 3.0503986636176705e-05, 2.913384378189221e-05, 3.5394044971326366e-05, 8.917841478250921e-05, 8.902756962925196e-05, 8.40499487821944e-05, 7.410731632262468e-05, 0.000304137181956321, 0.0002463063283357769, 0.00019113885355181992, 0.00015163220814429224, 0.00014374831516761333, 0.0001263721496798098, 0.0001030970161082223, 7.591275061713532e-05, 9.45868669077754e-05, 6.112661503721029e-05, 4.571501995087601e-05, 3.511730028549209e-05 ] }, "post_mlp_state": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.398412329464918e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6452634668607965, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.43809656983670076, "last_quartile_mean": 6.816459563196986e-05, "mean": 7.03343731061068e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6809932372926891, 0.7475632825133391, 0.6323153694166137, 0.6077851857944574, 0.7056447138179579, 0.5942446047107566, 0.530223262177042, 0.504089839823597, 0.6368974480554273, 0.5978888745536934, 0.5559539610577222, 0.5232972563751404, 0.4434509399790644, 0.41411238498840724, 0.4174418363858031, 0.5192489699581264, 1.2557404086895352, 1.2676084925356499, 1.1574347089891701, 1.060138766241709, 3.6189242296270336, 2.81239769967395, 2.2018329150221976, 1.7615672973682381, 1.8179181698124194, 1.4871187506667403, 1.086854135909831, 0.872703317202576, 0.8717669049561169, 0.6523365087620864, 0.4999226915339381, 0.46458383610897114 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6189242296270336, "population_cv": 0.7299683279122143, "rest_mean": 5.15456125598306e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.3328477735441013, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00017179368005599828, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.789723243447952e-05, 5.257939483271912e-05, 4.447350511327386e-05, 4.274819002603181e-05, 4.96310785820242e-05, 4.17958217440173e-05, 3.729292075149715e-05, 3.545484287315048e-05, 4.479578274185769e-05, 4.205213917884976e-05, 3.91026733268518e-05, 3.680578447529115e-05, 3.1189843866741285e-05, 2.9126334993634373e-05, 2.9360509870457463e-05, 3.65210507879965e-05, 8.83217144291848e-05, 8.915644866647199e-05, 8.140744466800243e-05, 7.45641955290921e-05, 0.0002545347670093179, 0.0001978082291316241, 0.000154864537762478, 0.00012389873154461384, 0.00012786213483195752, 0.00010459556506248191, 7.644320430699736e-05, 6.138104072306305e-05, 6.131517875473946e-05, 4.588167939800769e-05, 3.516174911055714e-05, 3.2676212867954746e-05 ] }, "pre_attention_input": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 2.7120979211758822e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.8594772224120714, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.15143095548529256, "last_quartile_mean": 3.1555204145661264e-05, "mean": 4.800072150601409e-05, "normalized": [ 0.509760479963835, 0.6173326836717695, 0.7324351629463104, 0.39842116793036353, 0.4759789060227602, 0.7458666061827044, 0.6096831903000134, 0.4306170616938511, 0.4047810550951731, 0.5961537125874838, 0.6210341956779442, 0.5605157741769637, 0.27837672031341976, 0.3443893546178484, 0.25310408037089555, 1.0527443019909122, 0.7465088513707779, 1.4090569908205048, 2.369608868078584, 2.622524932193837, 3.51885122958336, 3.2980052855840127, 2.541370727154349, 1.6037570225598534, 0.918310576031736, 1.0270328185033981, 1.0005888996255676, 0.5708475165844191, 0.6850494580580762, 0.5307877571911549, 0.29761830732641337, 0.22888630579170677 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.51885122958336, "population_cv": 0.8786708090610466, "rest_mean": 3.5768902374979075e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.1885950432011234, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00011405254481360317, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 20, 23, 19 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 2.446887083351612e-05, 2.96324142254889e-05, 3.515741627779789e-05, 1.912450352392625e-05, 2.2847330910735764e-05, 3.580213524401188e-05, 2.9265233024489135e-05, 2.0669929654104635e-05, 1.9429782696533948e-05, 2.8615808332688175e-05, 2.9810089472448453e-05, 2.6905161575996317e-05, 1.3362283425522037e-05, 1.653093750064727e-05, 1.2149178473919164e-05, 5.0532486056908965e-05, 3.5832963476423174e-05, 6.76357522024773e-05, 0.00011374293535482138, 0.00012588308891281486, 0.00016890739789232612, 0.00015830663323868066, 0.00012198762851767242, 7.698149420320988e-05, 4.407957021612674e-05, 4.929831629851833e-05, 4.802898911293596e-05, 2.7401092665968463e-05, 3.288286825409159e-05, 2.5478195311734453e-05, 1.4285893485066481e-05, 1.0986707820848096e-05 ] }, "pre_mlp_input": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 1.4786839983571554e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.1368590004352419, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 1.9888040770410698, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00010804433713929029, "mean": 6.53327875852483e-05, "normalized": [ 0.4303813973935663, 0.1954661274427069, 0.34854762874244455, 0.22114030543306437, 0.10883074349044422, 0.12627252893821267, 0.16836982659974983, 0.21164003420329566, 0.27785076214706256, 0.25390299121217014, 0.3323483997673342, 0.40930824768453605, 0.28788144954928885, 0.2920379121787492, 0.30710829102986115, 0.24768611608853355, 0.33445308089382414, 0.5081445956986791, 0.6162106751311494, 0.7807238268363051, 3.828274701557073, 3.4515650116091967, 2.7664213382241543, 2.2654046605337452, 2.2812415827715613, 2.1356021257971247, 2.0106696974531495, 1.537539473929636, 2.0088419319348305, 1.3422522168191928, 1.0598743605751482, 0.8540079583342102 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.828274701557073, "population_cv": 1.0279395854576847, "rest_mean": 4.2120514451569225e-05, "spike_contrast": 4.52698797699541, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0001906790625071153, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 2.8118016416556202e-05, 1.2770346984325442e-05, 2.2771588191972114e-05, 1.4447712601395324e-05, 7.110215847205836e-06, 8.249736310972366e-06, 1.1000070117006544e-05, 1.38270333991386e-05, 1.8152764823753387e-05, 1.6588190192123875e-05, 2.1713247406296432e-05, 2.6741248802863993e-05, 1.8808097593137063e-05, 1.9079650883213617e-05, 2.0064240743522532e-05, 1.6182024410227314e-05, 2.1850752091268077e-05, 3.3198502933373675e-05, 4.0258761146105826e-05, 5.1006863941438496e-05, 0.00025011185789480805, 0.0002255003637401387, 0.000180738017661497, 0.0001480052014812827, 0.00014903987175785005, 0.00013952484005130827, 0.00013136265624780208, 0.00010045173985417932, 0.0001312432432314381, 8.769307896727696e-05, 6.924454646650702e-05, 5.579472053796053e-05 ] } }, "post_mlp_reductions": { "batch_mean_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 1.1220713531656656e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6555413366591524, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.4222939165017446, "last_quartile_mean": 1.7116713934228756e-05, "mean": 1.7638015336274293e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6920608231884311, 0.7659177824262653, 0.6390754033749174, 0.6123424804403663, 0.7313911494807722, 0.6060429021656846, 0.5358717188243214, 0.5066293084101811, 0.6361394778273108, 0.5935071698997143, 0.5532047504443424, 0.5203003869133469, 0.4427001574083234, 0.41555518288954896, 0.42010731902783316, 0.5249828006548773, 1.2555950689969066, 1.2709301325611273, 1.1358461030518159, 1.0637808540376092, 3.605678554956403, 2.784492491030135, 2.1780228929741425, 1.7462695606216458, 1.8163019324419567, 1.491254439501435, 1.0911345614825427, 0.8818559802285882, 0.8715835151550508, 0.6503123816361532, 0.4986363533333601, 0.46247636461489006 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.605678554956403, "population_cv": 0.7234183193184713, "rest_mean": 1.2979772741851371e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.2968624487684486, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 4.2792525346158075e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 1.220657941303216e-05, 1.3509269592759665e-05, 1.1272021765762474e-05, 1.0800506061059423e-05, 1.2900288311357144e-05, 1.0689394002838526e-05, 9.451713594899047e-06, 8.935935511544812e-06, 1.122023786592763e-05, 1.0468288564879913e-05, 9.757433872437105e-06, 9.177066203847062e-06, 7.808352165739052e-06, 7.329568688874133e-06, 7.409859335893998e-06, 9.259654689230956e-06, 2.214620508311782e-05, 2.2416685169446282e-05, 2.003407098527532e-05, 1.876298301795032e-05, 6.359701364999637e-05, 4.911292126053013e-05, 3.841600118903443e-05, 3.080072929151356e-05, 3.203596133971587e-05, 2.630276867421344e-05, 1.9245448129368015e-05, 1.555418930365704e-05, 1.5373003407148644e-05, 1.1470219760667533e-05, 8.794955647317693e-06, 8.157165211741813e-06 ] }, "element_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.398412329464918e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6452634668607965, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.43809656983670076, "last_quartile_mean": 6.816459563196986e-05, "mean": 7.03343731061068e-05, "normalized": [ 0.6809932372926891, 0.7475632825133391, 0.6323153694166137, 0.6077851857944574, 0.7056447138179579, 0.5942446047107566, 0.530223262177042, 0.504089839823597, 0.6368974480554273, 0.5978888745536934, 0.5559539610577222, 0.5232972563751404, 0.4434509399790644, 0.41411238498840724, 0.4174418363858031, 0.5192489699581264, 1.2557404086895352, 1.2676084925356499, 1.1574347089891701, 1.060138766241709, 3.6189242296270336, 2.81239769967395, 2.2018329150221976, 1.7615672973682381, 1.8179181698124194, 1.4871187506667403, 1.086854135909831, 0.872703317202576, 0.8717669049561169, 0.6523365087620864, 0.4999226915339381, 0.46458383610897114 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6189242296270336, "population_cv": 0.7299683279122143, "rest_mean": 5.15456125598306e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.3328477735441013, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00017179368005599828, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.789723243447952e-05, 5.257939483271912e-05, 4.447350511327386e-05, 4.274819002603181e-05, 4.96310785820242e-05, 4.17958217440173e-05, 3.729292075149715e-05, 3.545484287315048e-05, 4.479578274185769e-05, 4.205213917884976e-05, 3.91026733268518e-05, 3.680578447529115e-05, 3.1189843866741285e-05, 2.9126334993634373e-05, 2.9360509870457463e-05, 3.65210507879965e-05, 8.83217144291848e-05, 8.915644866647199e-05, 8.140744466800243e-05, 7.45641955290921e-05, 0.0002545347670093179, 0.0001978082291316241, 0.000154864537762478, 0.00012389873154461384, 0.00012786213483195752, 0.00010459556506248191, 7.644320430699736e-05, 6.138104072306305e-05, 6.131517875473946e-05, 4.588167939800769e-05, 3.516174911055714e-05, 3.2676212867954746e-05 ] }, "global_l2": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 0.039005559869110584, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6452634722813873, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.43809656143611553, "last_quartile_mean": 0.06044904375448823, "mean": 0.06237322464585304, "normalized": [ 0.6809932518812878, 0.7475633220322179, 0.6323153569646397, 0.6077851973803072, 0.7056447145510248, 0.5942445836918125, 0.530223252027616, 0.5040898132583496, 0.6368974600710677, 0.5978889321237267, 0.5559539597752757, 0.523297269904143, 0.4434509324241475, 0.4141123687040429, 0.4174418427557242, 0.5192489959347639, 1.2557404102027183, 1.2676085225122937, 1.157434741358947, 1.0601387967701486, 3.61892435638739, 2.812397521737949, 2.201832924858681, 1.7615672286963322, 1.8179181559541986, 1.487118729202359, 1.086854143939758, 0.8727033118250799, 0.8717668711180101, 0.6523365178130685, 0.4999226849610752, 0.46458382918184327 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.61892435638739, "population_cv": 0.7299683256836244, "rest_mean": 0.045711164397222025, "spike_contrast": 3.3328477188762906, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.15234834998846053, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 0.04247574508190155, 0.04662793502211571, 0.039439547806978226, 0.03790952265262604, 0.044013336300849915, 0.03706495091319084, 0.03307173401117325, 0.03144170716404915, 0.039725348353385925, 0.03729226067662239, 0.03467664122581482, 0.03263973817229271, 0.02765946462750435, 0.02582952380180359, 0.026037193834781647, 0.03238723427057266, 0.0783245787024498, 0.07906483113765717, 0.07219293713569641, 0.06612427532672882, 0.2257239818572998, 0.17541830241680145, 0.1373354196548462, 0.10987462848424911, 0.11338941752910614, 0.09275639057159424, 0.06779059767723083, 0.054433319717645645, 0.05437491089105606, 0.04068833217024803, 0.031181789934635162, 0.028977591544389725 ] }, "token_mean_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 1.896312141980161e-06, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.40447227453095713, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.905172087401449, "last_quartile_mean": 4.688361258331497e-06, "mean": 3.997668517996544e-06, "normalized": [ 0.6172058310645722, 0.5425329228673286, 0.5226213455478163, 0.5130242205418598, 0.4179738021592733, 0.4022397236307717, 0.38715722309433015, 0.3920811131204843, 0.47573503087335345, 0.47091681751525505, 0.4692356598433531, 0.46858709630953144, 0.435518404119361, 0.43348810961922396, 0.457344361488258, 0.4834240606909693, 0.943243320831244, 0.9556851843891272, 0.9328847891755226, 0.9144352241016374, 3.593133434897055, 3.0161686306352355, 2.572714523011844, 2.200458051372808, 2.189693136620607, 1.8429744726585007, 1.3739587829516955, 1.1483183935808434, 1.0092761091983693, 0.7452413615169265, 0.5556410385724699, 0.5170878240003723 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.593133434897055, "population_cv": 0.8307777929041875, "rest_mean": 2.728457953135485e-06, "spike_contrast": 3.9771203202072667, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 1.0851405568246264e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 2.4673843199707335e-06, 2.1688667857233668e-06, 2.0892668999294983e-06, 2.050900775429909e-06, 1.670920710239443e-06, 1.6080210798463668e-06, 1.5477262422791682e-06, 1.567410322422802e-06, 1.901830955830519e-06, 1.8825693359758588e-06, 1.8758486248771078e-06, 1.8732558828560286e-06, 1.741058213156066e-06, 1.7329417687506066e-06, 1.8283111558048404e-06, 1.9325691482663387e-06, 3.770774128497578e-06, 3.820512574748136e-06, 3.7293641526048305e-06, 3.6556089071382303e-06, 1.4364156413648743e-05, 1.2057642379659228e-05, 1.0284859854436945e-05, 8.796701877145097e-06, 8.753667316341307e-06, 7.3676010288181715e-06, 5.49263177163084e-06, 4.590596290654503e-06, 4.0347513277083635e-06, 2.9792279292450985e-06, 2.2212686872080667e-06, 2.0671457150456263e-06 ] }, "token_rms_mean": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 3.3950954957617796e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.7815786467251918, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.24643949857917652, "last_quartile_mean": 4.343894897829159e-05, "mean": 4.974799179535694e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7500094412446059, 0.8083859646655934, 0.6989360803110847, 0.6730394265060721, 0.7487882742003255, 0.6472039809659893, 0.5806034653418889, 0.5527037948336986, 0.6849833016487895, 0.641463932771085, 0.5923270784846439, 0.5570934219720602, 0.5025383930607131, 0.4685801281186291, 0.467958282860767, 0.5622422290415673, 1.3163199357516149, 1.3145043099431595, 1.1718295263393368, 1.089421848322846, 3.6786851702332073, 2.7746307606104894, 2.0966820217393844, 1.6356296326692725, 1.680361539469081, 1.3632870777077486, 0.9862895783238333, 0.8095320290956769, 0.7283886637343489, 0.5544846482049088, 0.4452099057793211, 0.417886156048257 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6786851702332073, "population_cv": 0.710922698103497, "rest_mean": 3.709728177151798e-05, "spike_contrast": 3.18249263251226, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00011806182592408732, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 3.7311463529476896e-05, 4.021557833766565e-05, 3.477066638879478e-05, 3.348235986777581e-05, 3.725071292137727e-05, 3.219709833501838e-05, 2.8883856430184096e-05, 2.7495903850649484e-05, 3.407654367038049e-05, 3.191154246451333e-05, 2.946708264062181e-05, 2.7714278985513374e-05, 2.5000275854836218e-05, 2.3310920369112864e-05, 2.327998481632676e-05, 2.7970421797363088e-05, 6.548427336383611e-05, 6.539394962601364e-05, 5.8296165661886334e-05, 5.4196549172047526e-05, 0.00018300719966646284, 0.0001380323083139956, 0.0001043057200149633, 8.136928954627365e-05, 8.359461207874119e-05, 6.782079435652122e-05, 4.906592585030012e-05, 4.027259274153039e-05, 3.623587326728739e-05, 2.7584497729549184e-05, 2.21482987399213e-05, 2.078899706248194e-05 ] }, "token_rms_median": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 2.600453626655508e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.032180910721196, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.031673952782361334, "last_quartile_mean": 2.5193777560161834e-05, "mean": 3.414015603198095e-05, "normalized": [ 0.8380570158080917, 0.8932999084125006, 0.7929620023886231, 0.7615443521416788, 0.8187638282400099, 0.7186815599217726, 0.6527123798513835, 0.6175741300582618, 0.7513411682592698, 0.705872928051971, 0.6475562024934578, 0.6094685286755085, 0.5930459106503145, 0.5494388493370179, 0.5439464215496852, 0.6333820560847124, 1.4124654565316987, 1.425994860990475, 1.2380543674563398, 1.1313103339756791, 3.756835524951107, 2.7186060870583466, 1.87468091251249, 1.410793634954463, 1.4329939421834126, 1.1438971076949418, 0.8490265267268121, 0.7287288463621843, 0.5779352074283672, 0.4639524923457935, 0.36814597511060676, 0.33893148179302335 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.756835524951107, "population_cv": 0.6885594503102112, "rest_mean": 2.6308265020176163e-05, "spike_contrast": 2.9052606637917697, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 7.643236749572679e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, "values": [ 2.8611397283384576e-05, 3.0497398256557062e-05, 2.7071846488979645e-05, 2.599924300739076e-05, 2.795272484945599e-05, 2.4535900593036786e-05, 2.228370249213185e-05, 2.1084077161503956e-05, 2.5650904717622325e-05, 2.4098611902445555e-05, 2.21076697926037e-05, 2.0807350665563717e-05, 2.024667992372997e-05, 1.8757928046397865e-05, 1.8570415704743937e-05, 2.1623762222588994e-05, 4.82217910757754e-05, 4.86836870550178e-05, 4.226736928103492e-05, 3.8623111322522163e-05, 0.00012825895100831985, 9.281363600166515e-05, 6.400189886335284e-05, 4.816471482627094e-05, 4.89226367790252e-05, 3.905282574123703e-05, 2.898589809774421e-05, 2.4878916519810446e-05, 1.9730798157979734e-05, 1.5839410480111837e-05, 1.256856103282189e-05, 1.1571173672564328e-05 ] }, "token_rms_p95": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 8.909050666261464e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.6062699294291527, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.5004299639855584, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00014694858236907749, "mean": 0.00014725223013556388, "normalized": [ 0.6636255714147841, 0.7248917149077715, 0.6138660879695628, 0.5985975801010156, 0.6806345015153643, 0.5652332367621573, 0.5042378190281714, 0.4890714447869022, 0.6294477660992072, 0.5850399957826026, 0.5478904329704705, 0.518038310415621, 0.40778029155663986, 0.3853440981019431, 0.3845833582250337, 0.48007518680371525, 1.178544482689773, 1.1716070054101007, 1.1012637666749874, 1.0246953672401915, 3.668461219741745, 2.9054304267727518, 2.326469432391579, 1.8616676451976302, 1.8927854440285927, 1.5414183922061209, 1.1508159193509495, 0.9341585266360799, 0.8717798331906053, 0.6455697098701952, 0.49047863567768574, 0.45649679648005004 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.668461219741745, "population_cv": 0.7615887971484168, "rest_mean": 0.00010550450948627528, "spike_contrast": 3.5324549012779802, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0003726899216417223, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 9.772034536581486e-05, 0.00010674192162696272, 9.039315045811236e-05, 8.814482862362638e-05, 0.00010022494825534523, 8.323185465997085e-05, 7.42501433705911e-05, 7.201686094049364e-05, 9.268758731195703e-05, 8.614844409748912e-05, 8.067808812484145e-05, 7.628229650435969e-05, 6.004655733704567e-05, 5.674277781508863e-05, 5.663075717166066e-05, 7.06921418895945e-05, 0.00017354330339003354, 0.00017252174438908696, 0.00016216354561038315, 0.00015088867803569883, 0.0005401890957728028, 0.0004278311098460108, 0.00034257781226187944, 0.00027413471252657473, 0.0002787168778013438, 0.00022697729582432657, 0.00016946021059993654, 0.0001375569263473153, 0.0001283715246245265, 9.506157948635519e-05, 7.222407293738797e-05, 6.722017133142799e-05 ] } }, "seed": 2026073002 }, { "interventions": { "detached_learned": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 7.388767562588328e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.316792081076884, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.2751985371595874, "last_quartile_mean": 5.611187725662603e-05, "mean": 8.168265617314319e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7533431897136043, 0.7827542764436777, 0.7759396123840813, 0.7316445186865006, 1.1365162577009855, 1.1353975532420753, 1.004206629730762, 0.9167575048500237, 1.0078390566063014, 0.9220130731102486, 0.8550917608474935, 0.8013922543773514, 0.7721726808717908, 0.7274660564313035, 0.7065479131389877, 0.6779112969812525, 1.6398021444587536, 1.5049103837665865, 1.3267399301434915, 1.1597912607176666, 2.3220162536772593, 1.9302044249737353, 1.584049170842242, 1.3298950882483613, 1.2567261692224045, 0.9579394397382498, 0.801457903329196, 0.6752085554658249, 0.5811903488324587, 0.45264756329860717, 0.3896296913930569, 0.38079803677566654 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.3220162536772593, "population_cv": 0.4315618932878077, "rest_mean": 7.132743997283763e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.9291428895694742, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0001376008236547932, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 6.153507274575531e-05, 6.39374484308064e-05, 6.338080856949091e-05, 5.976266766083427e-05, 9.283366671297699e-05, 9.274228796130046e-05, 8.202626486308873e-05, 7.488318806281313e-05, 8.232297113863751e-05, 7.531247683800757e-05, 6.984616629779339e-05, 6.54598479741253e-05, 6.30731155979447e-05, 5.942135976511054e-05, 5.771271025878377e-05, 5.537359538720921e-05, 0.00013394339475780725, 0.00012292507744859904, 0.00010837164154509082, 9.473483078181744e-05, 0.0001896684552775696, 0.00015766422438900918, 0.0001293893437832594, 0.00010862936323974282, 0.00010265273158438504, 7.824703789083287e-05, 6.546521035488695e-05, 5.515282828127965e-05, 4.7473171434830874e-05, 3.69734552805312e-05, 3.1825988116906956e-05, 3.1104595109354705e-05 ] }, "learned": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 8.156212697940646e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.3967870279562358, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.33417461908716395, "last_quartile_mean": 5.839267214469146e-05, "mean": 8.757388354752038e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7720675832605176, 0.803585946279625, 0.7960780094481321, 0.752473219070419, 1.180467409539882, 1.1778079020041263, 1.029829529518624, 0.9385078067458692, 1.0206984705622164, 0.9298229900567075, 0.8640759923745102, 0.8130195958778703, 0.7736070401530517, 0.7280910766467854, 0.7061969571118035, 0.6826252956632183, 1.642168884788434, 1.5117445082936212, 1.3334176736203447, 1.1637251407789435, 2.2882673690329693, 1.8954517085610634, 1.5552436162725376, 1.306771834154562, 1.2228641636923565, 0.9319785952743014, 0.7801153976292595, 0.661371584878177, 0.561946672486053, 0.4345672285647456, 0.37483694087850516, 0.36657385678076787 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2882673690329693, "population_cv": 0.42684708327825066, "rest_mean": 7.697225831819836e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.8814916302334765, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0001448226597858593, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 6.761295662727207e-05, 7.037314207991585e-05, 6.971564289415255e-05, 6.589700205950066e-05, 0.00010337811545468867, 0.00010314521205145866, 9.018617129186168e-05, 8.218877337640151e-05, 8.93865289981477e-05, 8.14282102510333e-05, 7.567049033241346e-05, 7.11992834112607e-05, 6.774777284590527e-05, 6.376176315825433e-05, 6.184441008372232e-05, 5.9780148149002343e-05, 0.00014381110668182373, 0.00013238933752290905, 0.0001167725640698336, 0.00010191192995989695, 0.0002003924601012841, 0.0001659920671954751, 0.0001361987233394757, 0.00011443908442743123, 0.00010709096386563033, 8.16169849713333e-05, 6.831773498561233e-05, 5.791887815576047e-05, 4.921185245621018e-05, 3.8056739867897704e-05, 3.282592660980299e-05, 3.210229624528438e-05 ] }, "uniform_value_backward": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 3.5575103993323864e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 2.443213468991071, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.893314168315378, "last_quartile_mean": 1.456078416595119e-05, "mean": 2.3831100747884193e-05, "normalized": [ 1.614905261758675, 1.6568148874352646, 1.6283515751571318, 1.4605379751384047, 1.4717695441533916, 1.4559185813526447, 1.358376097224691, 1.295738430337987, 1.1776907075521434, 1.1141057290944703, 1.0640572841848701, 1.0269673379730528, 1.0041631647243947, 0.9733861101490422, 0.9597079874490758, 0.9349675920893245, 0.9158525986134215, 0.9066797587654788, 0.890357239209801, 0.8734858422464332, 0.8579185157197757, 0.8414715045701692, 0.8239471946120328, 0.8048352542714806, 0.7658980848440458, 0.7173626211575344, 0.6794957283273223, 0.6347225670052176, 0.5854538165358278, 0.5328910383364602, 0.49362355782826073, 0.47854641218217414 ], "peak_layer": 2, "peak_normalized": 1.6568148874352646, "population_cv": 0.33383138748240165, "rest_mean": 2.4630704299650257e-05, "spike_contrast": 0.7922323832463255, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 1.951324156834744e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 2, 3, 1, 5, 4 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 0 }, "values": [ 3.848496999125928e-05, 3.94837225030642e-05, 3.880541044054553e-05, 3.48062276316341e-05, 3.507388828438707e-05, 3.4696142392931506e-05, 3.237159762647934e-05, 3.087887307628989e-05, 2.8065665901522152e-05, 2.6550365873845294e-05, 2.535765634092968e-05, 2.4473762096022256e-05, 2.393031354586128e-05, 2.3196862457552925e-05, 2.2870897737448104e-05, 2.2281306883087382e-05, 2.182577554776799e-05, 2.1607176677207462e-05, 2.1218193069216795e-05, 2.081612910842523e-05, 2.0445142581593245e-05, 2.0053192201885395e-05, 1.9635568605735898e-05, 1.9180110029992647e-05, 1.825219442253001e-05, 1.7095540897571482e-05, 1.6193131159525365e-05, 1.5126137441257015e-05, 1.3952008885098621e-05, 1.2699380022240803e-05, 1.176359273813432e-05, 1.1404287761251908e-05 ] } }, "position_element_rms": { "attention_branch_output": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 8.209008865378564e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.1473326374136463, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.13743980256699795, "last_quartile_mean": 7.154863897085306e-05, "mean": 9.638685185109352e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7014672692081079, 0.730745142012726, 0.7197152784749434, 0.6836365522681692, 1.073826467208612, 1.0803379033203697, 0.9514146538604249, 0.8722415119444402, 1.0096074578076277, 0.8908657485913869, 0.8272757726491637, 0.7688961382914924, 0.7419179025068791, 0.6953651992846211, 0.6657440869339828, 0.6349379036282153, 1.6060213837194506, 1.5018800747743897, 1.362846846779478, 1.1942969804897212, 2.2656295070514414, 2.0104706485090547, 1.6756941049043201, 1.3967091226783026, 1.3149112210845808, 1.1000992011684827, 0.8430071951587476, 0.7025118587919716, 0.7359466516142374, 0.5075845580254474, 0.3944123577040649, 0.33998329955514606 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2656295070514414, "population_cv": 0.4413317448728873, "rest_mean": 8.330888886121102e-05, "spike_contrast": 2.004682264754327, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00016700785199645906, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 17, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 6.761222175555304e-05, 7.043422374408692e-05, 6.93710899213329e-05, 6.589357508346438e-05, 0.00010350275260861963, 0.00010413036943646148, 9.17038632906042e-05, 8.407261339016259e-05, 9.731288446346298e-05, 8.586774492869154e-05, 7.973850733833387e-05, 7.411147817038e-05, 7.15111309546046e-05, 6.70240624458529e-05, 6.416897667804733e-05, 6.119966565165669e-05, 0.0001547993451822549, 0.00014476149226538837, 0.0001313605171162635, 0.0001151145261246711, 0.00021837689564563334, 0.00019378293654881418, 0.00016151487943716347, 0.00013462439528666437, 0.00012674015306401998, 0.00010603509872453287, 8.125480962917209e-05, 6.771290645701811e-05, 7.093558087944984e-05, 4.8924477596301585e-05, 3.801616549026221e-05, 3.2769919926067814e-05 ] }, "mlp_branch_output": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 8.156287549354602e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.3967979973430424, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.3341824723557829, "last_quartile_mean": 5.839274945174111e-05, "mean": 8.75740092851629e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7720751985061499, 0.8035956764433113, 0.7960739585260428, 0.7524919125585545, 1.1804156983562801, 1.1778760010857563, 1.0298326204965722, 0.9385140198493713, 1.0207128740101707, 0.929812017339553, 0.8640701821512353, 0.8130222503970004, 0.7736044339144612, 0.7280851293348032, 0.7061941984091654, 0.6826155087046274, 1.642189790371069, 1.511740343745529, 1.3334033796706957, 1.1637276240936476, 2.2882576030527964, 1.895449319429852, 1.5552551751392194, 1.3067312409844312, 1.222859749246748, 0.9319757616478574, 0.7801162715542103, 0.6613743325062905, 0.561952429248885, 0.43456344744462927, 0.3748431739999157, 0.36656867778116903 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2882576030527964, "population_cv": 0.4268460433011898, "rest_mean": 7.697251674943362e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.8814776376552176, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00014482206897810103, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 6.761372060282156e-05, 7.037409523036331e-05, 6.971538823563606e-05, 6.589873373741284e-05, 0.00010337373532820493, 0.00010315132385585457, 9.018657146953046e-05, 8.21894354885444e-05, 8.9387918706052e-05, 8.142736623995006e-05, 7.567009015474468e-05, 7.119961810531095e-05, 6.774764187866822e-05, 6.376133387675509e-05, 6.184425728861243e-05, 5.977937689749524e-05, 0.0001438131439499557, 0.0001323891628999263, 0.00011677147995214909, 0.00010191229375777766, 0.00020039189257659018, 0.00016599209629930556, 0.00013619993114843965, 0.00011443569383118302, 0.00010709073103498667, 8.161685400409624e-05, 6.831790960859507e-05, 5.79192019358743e-05, 4.92124272568617e-05, 3.8056463381508365e-05, 3.282651960034855e-05, 3.2101888791657984e-05 ] }, "post_attention_state": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 8.209185853047529e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.1473585117140146, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.13746235401177884, "last_quartile_mean": 7.154856803026632e-05, "mean": 9.638741801154538e-05, "normalized": [ 0.701459601059617, 0.7307291493400122, 0.7197289413331719, 0.6836538994288254, 1.0739127818136336, 1.080318121017968, 0.9514366180464413, 0.8722525427024255, 1.0096073400424832, 0.8908667057242938, 0.8272733289673383, 0.7688963021177191, 0.7419276606217693, 0.6953759857067083, 0.6657591236204922, 0.6349357593481342, 1.6060262927227642, 1.5018600810151583, 1.362811062623623, 1.194289437021534, 2.265619973525555, 2.010448271283051, 1.6756913579512287, 1.3967040891245648, 1.314898968363092, 1.100096740194715, 0.8429885804297745, 0.7025081852971004, 0.7359520665807775, 0.5075723672109625, 0.3944131736981434, 0.33998549206692247 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.265619973525555, "population_cv": 0.44132695283622186, "rest_mean": 8.330956363890975e-05, "spike_contrast": 2.0046657830023333, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00016700783162377776, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 17, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 6.761187978554517e-05, 7.043309597065672e-05, 6.937281432328746e-05, 6.58956341794692e-05, 0.00010351168020861223, 0.00010412907431600615, 9.170651901513338e-05, 8.407417044509202e-05, 9.731344471219927e-05, 8.58683415572159e-05, 7.973874016897753e-05, 7.411192927975208e-05, 7.151249155867845e-05, 6.70254958095029e-05, 6.417080294340849e-05, 6.119981844676659e-05, 0.0001548007276142016, 0.00014476041542366147, 0.0001313578395638615, 0.0001151144751929678, 0.00021837725944351405, 0.0001937819179147482, 0.0001615155633771792, 0.00013462470087688416, 0.00012673971650656313, 0.00010603548435028642, 8.125349268084392e-05, 6.771295011276379e-05, 7.093651947798207e-05, 4.8923589929472655e-05, 3.80164674425032e-05, 3.27703237417154e-05 ] }, "post_mlp_state": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 8.156212697940646e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.3967870279562358, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.33417461908716395, "last_quartile_mean": 5.839267214469146e-05, "mean": 8.757388354752038e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7720675832605176, 0.803585946279625, 0.7960780094481321, 0.752473219070419, 1.180467409539882, 1.1778079020041263, 1.029829529518624, 0.9385078067458692, 1.0206984705622164, 0.9298229900567075, 0.8640759923745102, 0.8130195958778703, 0.7736070401530517, 0.7280910766467854, 0.7061969571118035, 0.6826252956632183, 1.642168884788434, 1.5117445082936212, 1.3334176736203447, 1.1637251407789435, 2.2882673690329693, 1.8954517085610634, 1.5552436162725376, 1.306771834154562, 1.2228641636923565, 0.9319785952743014, 0.7801153976292595, 0.661371584878177, 0.561946672486053, 0.4345672285647456, 0.37483694087850516, 0.36657385678076787 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2882673690329693, "population_cv": 0.42684708327825066, "rest_mean": 7.697225831819836e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.8814916302334765, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0001448226597858593, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 6.761295662727207e-05, 7.037314207991585e-05, 6.971564289415255e-05, 6.589700205950066e-05, 0.00010337811545468867, 0.00010314521205145866, 9.018617129186168e-05, 8.218877337640151e-05, 8.93865289981477e-05, 8.14282102510333e-05, 7.567049033241346e-05, 7.11992834112607e-05, 6.774777284590527e-05, 6.376176315825433e-05, 6.184441008372232e-05, 5.9780148149002343e-05, 0.00014381110668182373, 0.00013238933752290905, 0.0001167725640698336, 0.00010191192995989695, 0.0002003924601012841, 0.0001659920671954751, 0.0001361987233394757, 0.00011443908442743123, 0.00010709096386563033, 8.16169849713333e-05, 6.831773498561233e-05, 5.791887815576047e-05, 4.921185245621018e-05, 3.8056739867897704e-05, 3.282592660980299e-05, 3.210229624528438e-05 ] }, "pre_attention_input": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.013745751763054e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.3002217470857882, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.26253482460265976, "last_quartile_mean": 3.0869701731717214e-05, "mean": 5.617674656832605e-05, "normalized": [ 0.473654064493233, 0.5256902444154287, 0.3705068590661575, 0.5387329076786941, 0.37665460925127686, 0.9021763170314637, 1.3591261829588805, 1.169340915014312, 1.4504557484696843, 1.2215794360380687, 0.9103877586499164, 0.9321134746924985, 0.5414129154069731, 0.8525397685215896, 0.9808579608967221, 0.9142526712062526, 1.0619023556310665, 1.8034129735144708, 1.5888135435441055, 1.899281403844036, 1.9024910148779852, 2.5497535502321647, 2.089500431013523, 1.18928036938163, 1.0430326636758747, 0.9143825787913804, 0.5551399248346642, 0.5581364123079678, 0.38887965127025986, 0.4518317596354874, 0.24874412658654727, 0.2359354070676856 ], "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 2.5497535502321647, "population_cv": 0.5766137085977164, "rest_mean": 4.832436503353098e-05, "spike_contrast": 2.0399565889343343, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 9.857960685621947e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 22, 23, 21, 20, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 2.6608344342093915e-05, 2.9531567633966915e-05, 2.0813869923586026e-05, 3.0264262022683397e-05, 2.1159230527700856e-05, 5.0681330321822315e-05, 7.635128713445738e-05, 6.568976823473349e-05, 8.148188499035314e-05, 6.862435839138925e-05, 5.114262239658274e-05, 5.236310244072229e-05, 3.041481613763608e-05, 4.7892910515656695e-05, 5.510140908882022e-05, 5.135974060976878e-05, 5.9654219512594864e-05, 0.00010130987357115373, 8.925437578000128e-05, 0.00010669545008568093, 0.00010687575559131801, 0.00014323685900308192, 0.00011738133616745472, 6.680990190943703e-05, 5.859418160980567e-05, 5.1367038395255804e-05, 3.1185954867396504e-05, 3.1354287784779444e-05, 2.18459936149884e-05, 2.538243825256359e-05, 1.397363575961208e-05, 1.3254083569336217e-05 ] }, "pre_mlp_input": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 2.0563243310789403e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.184584542859635, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 1.6896476935739415, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00011140284550492652, "mean": 8.183052003118974e-05, "normalized": [ 0.5514618447323059, 0.2169408826973503, 0.08472485593965659, 0.28295099514537675, 0.21989392642956848, 0.1303640614627248, 0.17290402482659964, 0.35108448581118906, 0.6388397786640535, 0.4693907558756991, 0.4878178928069798, 0.4684568375678178, 0.5735758405807379, 0.5222431877258841, 0.48692296371012395, 0.47894342377930604, 1.3828038952387727, 1.4137992065669855, 1.4773604231197706, 1.4101154596735193, 2.482879371711871, 2.526943137473127, 2.259311590178407, 2.019190865749238, 2.085961378955964, 1.8764944434843154, 1.4765035496268348, 1.350239590483524, 1.4291199659133378, 1.0658000032658883, 0.838995628185017, 0.7679657326180543 ], "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 2.526943137473127, "population_cv": 0.7282772544392188, "rest_mean": 6.251158794367695e-05, "spike_contrast": 2.977891930556664, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0001861527533037588, "top_five_layers": [ 22, 21, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 4.51264095318038e-05, 1.7752385247149505e-05, 6.933079021109734e-06, 2.3154027076088823e-05, 1.7994034351431765e-05, 1.0667758942872752e-05, 1.4148826267046388e-05, 2.8729426048812456e-05, 5.2276591304689646e-05, 3.841048965114169e-05, 3.9918391848914325e-05, 3.833406663034111e-05, 4.6936009312048554e-05, 4.2735431634355336e-05, 3.984515933552757e-05, 3.91921894333791e-05, 0.00011315556184854358, 0.00011569192429305986, 0.00012089317169738933, 0.00011539048136910424, 0.00020317531016189605, 0.00020678107102867216, 0.00018488064233679324, 0.00016523143858648837, 0.00017069530440494418, 0.0001535545161459595, 0.00012082305329386145, 0.00011049080785596743, 0.00011694562999764457, 8.721496851649135e-05, 6.865544855827466e-05, 6.2843035266269e-05 ] } }, "post_mlp_reductions": { "batch_mean_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 2.0823702925554244e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.4242510302785252, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.35364608276130804, "last_quartile_mean": 1.4620809452026151e-05, "mean": 2.2054440051988422e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7841928807641645, 0.8183408510588258, 0.809986731151413, 0.7637938668182616, 1.192276091281044, 1.1966830153099992, 1.039215154291241, 0.9490753634193776, 1.0189872806238243, 0.9331490903420598, 0.8658120301757168, 0.81301306861575, 0.7774052511262896, 0.7266654164061733, 0.7030327996851689, 0.6829495498627286, 1.6322510246428148, 1.499422250137046, 1.3169815172043178, 1.1572342326306069, 2.2864238933994527, 1.8918479809103845, 1.543069371898747, 1.294657154506133, 1.2171810844243176, 0.9287685590307506, 0.7771677166674748, 0.6578712720326597, 0.5567773486562734, 0.43254113576640124, 0.3708732313504376, 0.3623537858101448 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2864238933994527, "population_cv": 0.4245664907667088, "rest_mean": 1.9413478454495175e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.8706401721656991, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 3.6315632678451947e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 1.729493487800937e-05, 1.804804924177006e-05, 1.78638038050849e-05, 1.684504604781978e-05, 2.629498158057686e-05, 2.639217382238712e-05, 2.2919308321434073e-05, 2.093132570735179e-05, 2.2473193894256838e-05, 2.0580080672516488e-05, 1.9094999515800737e-05, 1.7930547983269207e-05, 1.7145237507065758e-05, 1.6026198863983154e-05, 1.5504994735238142e-05, 1.5062069905980024e-05, 3.5998382372781634e-05, 3.306891812826507e-05, 2.9045289920759387e-05, 2.5522153009660542e-05, 5.0425798690412194e-05, 4.172364788246341e-05, 3.403153095860034e-05, 2.855293860193342e-05, 2.6844247258850373e-05, 2.048347050731536e-05, 1.7139998817583546e-05, 1.450898253096966e-05, 1.2279412658244837e-05, 9.539452548779082e-06, 8.179401447705459e-06, 7.991509846760891e-06 ] }, "element_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 8.156212697940646e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.3967870279562358, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.33417461908716395, "last_quartile_mean": 5.839267214469146e-05, "mean": 8.757388354752038e-05, "normalized": [ 0.7720675832605176, 0.803585946279625, 0.7960780094481321, 0.752473219070419, 1.180467409539882, 1.1778079020041263, 1.029829529518624, 0.9385078067458692, 1.0206984705622164, 0.9298229900567075, 0.8640759923745102, 0.8130195958778703, 0.7736070401530517, 0.7280910766467854, 0.7061969571118035, 0.6826252956632183, 1.642168884788434, 1.5117445082936212, 1.3334176736203447, 1.1637251407789435, 2.2882673690329693, 1.8954517085610634, 1.5552436162725376, 1.306771834154562, 1.2228641636923565, 0.9319785952743014, 0.7801153976292595, 0.661371584878177, 0.561946672486053, 0.4345672285647456, 0.37483694087850516, 0.36657385678076787 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2882673690329693, "population_cv": 0.42684708327825066, "rest_mean": 7.697225831819836e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.8814916302334765, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.0001448226597858593, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 6.761295662727207e-05, 7.037314207991585e-05, 6.971564289415255e-05, 6.589700205950066e-05, 0.00010337811545468867, 0.00010314521205145866, 9.018617129186168e-05, 8.218877337640151e-05, 8.93865289981477e-05, 8.14282102510333e-05, 7.567049033241346e-05, 7.11992834112607e-05, 6.774777284590527e-05, 6.376176315825433e-05, 6.184441008372232e-05, 5.9780148149002343e-05, 0.00014381110668182373, 0.00013238933752290905, 0.0001167725640698336, 0.00010191192995989695, 0.0002003924601012841, 0.0001659920671954751, 0.0001361987233394757, 0.00011443908442743123, 0.00010709096386563033, 8.16169849713333e-05, 6.831773498561233e-05, 5.791887815576047e-05, 4.921185245621018e-05, 3.8056739867897704e-05, 3.282592660980299e-05, 3.210229624528438e-05 ] }, "global_l2": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 0.07233011117205024, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.3967870631582553, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.3341746442893017, "last_quartile_mean": 0.051783205242827535, "mean": 0.07766139676095918, "normalized": [ 0.7720675426341356, 0.8035859729306402, 0.7960780122636479, 0.7524732326455996, 1.1804674279966365, 1.1778079658527474, 1.0298294903648106, 0.9385077949910019, 1.020698424099846, 0.9298230264026498, 0.8640760490713295, 0.8130195756795249, 0.773607039370292, 0.7280910561484961, 0.7061969508238138, 0.6826252958058289, 1.64216899408666, 1.511744542110794, 1.3334176327397504, 1.1637251251728324, 2.288267386572505, 1.8954517517435265, 1.5552435035136007, 1.3067718770227776, 1.2228641722871045, 0.9319785328940787, 0.7801153392913037, 0.6613715681663117, 0.5619466726726858, 0.43456725256605405, 0.37483694737332934, 0.36657384470568466 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.288267386572505, "population_cv": 0.4268470914878033, "rest_mean": 0.0682597693607763, "spike_contrast": 1.8814916300573643, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.12843018472194673, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 0.05995984375476837, 0.062407609075307846, 0.061824530363082886, 0.058438122272491455, 0.0916767492890358, 0.09147021174430847, 0.07997799664735794, 0.07288582623004913, 0.07926886528730392, 0.072211354970932, 0.06710535287857056, 0.06314023584127426, 0.06007940322160721, 0.05654456838965416, 0.054844241589307785, 0.0530136339366436, 0.12753313779830933, 0.11740419268608093, 0.10355507582426071, 0.09037651866674423, 0.17771004140377045, 0.14720343053340912, 0.12078238278627396, 0.1014857292175293, 0.09496933966875076, 0.07237875461578369, 0.06058484688401222, 0.05136303976178169, 0.04364156350493431, 0.03374909982085228, 0.029110360890626907, 0.02846863679587841 ] }, "token_mean_rms": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 3.1000530213987076e-06, "first_to_last_ratio": 0.7825005490137864, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.2452606549530124, "last_quartile_mean": 3.961726321222159e-06, "mean": 4.656059921614997e-06, "normalized": [ 0.7040313055728622, 0.6663442620495864, 0.6544029514954961, 0.6681637652166335, 0.6743674803950376, 0.6670078174062475, 0.6466284443239834, 0.6455370061269436, 0.7660325155889827, 0.7325145706427032, 0.7131598309497137, 0.7280186266136806, 0.64870437442493, 0.656793469733594, 0.6699169519151534, 0.7314456448845376, 1.53365232903732, 1.4601427212016398, 1.3940973786195396, 1.306558663485338, 2.534675981169938, 2.2580403975857246, 1.9597194264610087, 1.773041790596292, 1.6211455309545355, 1.2094494759638503, 1.0219317012739941, 0.8604275624593173, 0.6846808632651675, 0.5134649266877133, 0.4503974279453127, 0.4455048059532228 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.534675981169938, "population_cv": 0.5361438958058841, "rest_mean": 3.768541933755774e-06, "spike_contrast": 2.5072447705625382, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 9.4486570560548e-06, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, "values": [ 3.2780119454400847e-06, 3.1025388125272e-06, 3.046939355044742e-06, 3.1110105283005396e-06, 3.1398953979078215e-06, 3.105628366029123e-06, 3.0107407837931532e-06, 3.005658982146997e-06, 3.566693294487777e-06, 3.4106317343685078e-06, 3.320514906590688e-06, 3.389698349565151e-06, 3.020406438736245e-06, 3.058069751205039e-06, 3.119173470622627e-06, 3.405654751986731e-06, 7.140777142922161e-06, 6.798512004024815e-06, 6.4910009314189665e-06, 6.083415428292938e-06, 1.1801603250205517e-05, 1.0513571396586485e-05, 9.12457107915543e-06, 8.255388820543885e-06, 7.548150733782677e-06, 5.631269232253544e-06, 4.758175236929674e-06, 4.006202289019711e-06, 3.187915126545704e-06, 2.3907234663056443e-06, 2.0970774130546488e-06, 2.074297071885667e-06 ] }, "token_rms_mean": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 5.95857286498358e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.5974327409797537, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.4683978037101298, "last_quartile_mean": 3.7300931126083015e-05, "mean": 6.105390025368251e-05, "normalized": [ 0.8419145460820371, 0.8656854461464137, 0.8583401181387939, 0.8192663123570689, 1.1963719080724353, 1.1751919414919585, 1.0676149913033914, 0.9832376272965914, 1.0816749854357006, 0.984736879340849, 0.9088680283961561, 0.8483339022774173, 0.8441772779737997, 0.7882426814662962, 0.7677338358974833, 0.7384876656990601, 1.5920129687595903, 1.4697744406924866, 1.283993033566668, 1.1290203889690138, 2.340760926498109, 1.860435632123778, 1.4645539617726704, 1.2019638482713701, 1.15797649283655, 0.8703237664687024, 0.7241030451553558, 0.6218659849233957, 0.4685510324632258, 0.37521378882561096, 0.3379462835275562, 0.3316262577704645 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.340760926498109, "population_cv": 0.4213559298637173, "rest_mean": 5.4212039955288036e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.8077155175462722, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 9.79999458650127e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 18, 23 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 5.140216671861708e-05, 5.285347288008779e-05, 5.240501195657998e-05, 5.0019403715850785e-05, 7.304317114176229e-05, 7.175005157478154e-05, 6.518205918837339e-05, 6.003049202263355e-05, 6.604047666769475e-05, 6.012202720739879e-05, 5.548993794946e-05, 5.1794093451462686e-05, 5.154031532583758e-05, 4.8125290049938485e-05, 4.687314503826201e-05, 4.5087552280165255e-05, 9.7198600997217e-05, 8.973546209745109e-05, 7.839278259780258e-05, 6.8931098212488e-05, 0.000142912584124133, 0.00011358685151208192, 8.941673149820417e-05, 7.338458090089262e-05, 7.069898128975183e-05, 5.3136660426389426e-05, 4.420931509230286e-05, 3.796734381467104e-05, 2.8606867999769747e-05, 2.2908265236765146e-05, 2.0632938685594127e-05, 2.0247076463419944e-05 ] }, "token_rms_median": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 4.39446339441929e-05, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.9902838030955072, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.6882772431887607, "last_quartile_mean": 2.207958175404201e-05, "mean": 4.171556903997953e-05, "normalized": [ 0.9393219483952423, 0.9671725353750462, 0.9606035942825071, 0.9165296658237206, 1.25754251069206, 1.233040231347365, 1.1241638961033311, 1.029104366181827, 1.1530467776467852, 1.041181174787795, 0.9503458810810488, 0.8874956508445306, 0.9380795670187313, 0.868712023499227, 0.8459898570744635, 0.811097306638917, 1.57041471098841, 1.447423664007262, 1.250399123009104, 1.0954141829132344, 2.392471764387743, 1.7753028127291355, 1.2921083756975622, 1.0187283101804303, 1.065894151409315, 0.8051193818729687, 0.6754751497722067, 0.6026093861097862, 0.3198852539229254, 0.2669904264118248, 0.2517857094641488, 0.2465506103313451 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.392471764387743, "population_cv": 0.4303681174959756, "rest_mean": 3.778425454786177e-05, "spike_contrast": 1.6658967617763285, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 6.294466729741543e-05, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 18, 23 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 3.9184349589049816e-05, 4.034615267300978e-05, 4.007212555734441e-05, 3.823355655185878e-05, 5.245910142548382e-05, 5.1436974899843335e-05, 4.689513662015088e-05, 4.2929674236802384e-05, 4.810000245925039e-05, 4.343346517998725e-05, 3.9644219214096665e-05, 3.702238609548658e-05, 3.913252294296399e-05, 3.6238816392142326e-05, 3.5290948289912194e-05, 3.3835385693237185e-05, 6.551074329763651e-05, 6.0380101785995066e-05, 5.2161110943416134e-05, 4.5695825974689797e-05, 9.980332106351852e-05, 7.40577670512721e-05, 5.3901036153547466e-05, 4.249683115631342e-05, 4.446438106242567e-05, 3.358601315994747e-05, 2.8177830245113e-05, 2.513819345040247e-05, 1.3344195394893177e-05, 1.113765756599605e-05, 1.0503384146431927e-05, 1.0284999007126316e-05 ] }, "token_rms_p95": { "statistics": { "first_quartile_mean": 0.00015719397015345749, "first_to_last_ratio": 1.2580343238755638, "imbalance_abs_log_ratio": 0.22955044238581457, "last_quartile_mean": 0.00012495205191953573, "mean": 0.00018078252287523355, "normalized": [ 0.7253227592072276, 0.7485993006094415, 0.7410050906139998, 0.7104508417729404, 1.0745241672934553, 1.0524252536641314, 0.9748384190355198, 0.9289919933888637, 1.0038768041568893, 0.9389629508381758, 0.8789427325469985, 0.8198897306139241, 0.7627520038160613, 0.7096499260969147, 0.6897553416925117, 0.6787601781063402, 1.6052869610938005, 1.5071148227224969, 1.3317635520239959, 1.1792135859285877, 2.364258320942869, 1.9856700690456726, 1.6414783683894763, 1.4170804705838413, 1.2788477375082987, 0.9694880608375548, 0.8072605380605845, 0.691415531221962, 0.5679201295495192, 0.44599504581333255, 0.3904354851204105, 0.3780238277042025 ], "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.364258320942869, "population_cv": 0.4451626458968529, "rest_mean": 0.0001560934222113617, "spike_contrast": 2.0122799667677387, "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "spike_mean": 0.00031410366646014156, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 17, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, "values": [ 0.00013112567830830812, 0.0001353336701868102, 0.00013396076974458992, 0.00012843709555454552, 0.00019425518985372037, 0.0001902600924950093, 0.00017623374878894538, 0.00016794551629573107, 0.00018148338131140918, 0.00016974809113889933, 0.00015889748465269804, 0.0001482217339798808, 0.00013789223157800734, 0.00012829230399802327, 0.00012469571083784103, 0.00012270797742530704, 0.00029020782676525414, 0.00027246001991443336, 0.00024075957480818033, 0.0002131812070729211, 0.00042741658398881555, 0.0003589744446799159, 0.00029675060068257153, 0.00025618338258937, 0.0002311933203600347, 0.00017526649753563106, 0.00014593859668821096, 0.0001249958440894261, 0.00010267003381159157, 8.062810957198963e-05, 7.058391202008352e-05, 6.834010127931833e-05 ] } }, "seed": 2026073003 } ], "gates": { "forward_identity": [ { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073001 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073002 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073003 } ], "initialization_negative_control": [ { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073001 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073002 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073003 } ], "loss_scale": [ { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073001 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073002 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073003 } ], "replay": { "checks": { "architecture": true, "artifacts": true, "batch_size": true, "depth": true, "diagnostics": true, "environment": true, "evaluations": true, "hashes": true, "manifest": true, "model": true, "optimizer": true, "round05_equivalence": true, "seed": true, "steps": true, "target_bytes_seen": true, "training_history": true }, "frozen_compare_sha256": "05396eaf56429ca8d87815ecf00a5f78be5a9b2ec7cc96014856c09dcedcbb87", "passed": true }, "round05_equivalence": [ { "checks": { "evaluations": true, "final_model_state": true, "final_optimizer_state": true, "post_mlp_element_rms_all_steps": true, "training_history": true }, "passed": true, "seed": 2026073001 }, { "checks": { "evaluations": true, "final_model_state": true, "final_optimizer_state": true, "post_mlp_element_rms_all_steps": true, "training_history": true }, "passed": true, "seed": 2026073002 }, { "checks": { "evaluations": true, "final_model_state": true, "final_optimizer_state": true, "post_mlp_element_rms_all_steps": true, "training_history": true }, "passed": true, "seed": 2026073003 } ] }, "hashes": { "aggregate_canonical_sha256": "1d0faef297682d61d35ce2ab54da3868e18a84e9ebc6e44c617d08016e4fc8b4", "reproduction_canonical_sha256": "7c522314742920961be84b750d823ce41814f10fd6129f0531208116e2fe3515" }, "mixer_associations": { "all_layers": { "attention_entropy": { "pearson": -0.29619123279185056, "spearman": -0.2883517139673049 }, "attention_latest": { "pearson": 0.06600313295625082, "spearman": 0.29780653565593507 }, "attention_max": { "pearson": -0.024396635036849867, "spearman": 0.20476403642736357 }, "mlp_entropy": { "pearson": -0.2736346519450915, "spearman": -0.41707813347802497 }, "mlp_latest": { "pearson": 0.6507856318169407, "spearman": 0.692444384156267 }, "mlp_max": { "pearson": 0.23015916710007592, "spearman": 0.4651112316874661 }, "points": 96 }, "identity": "observational association; not causal attribution", "layers_19_28": { "attention_entropy": { "pearson": -0.05745838348637786, "spearman": -0.11279199110122358 }, "attention_latest": { "pearson": 0.15799271238887527, "spearman": 0.3388209121245829 }, "attention_max": { "pearson": 0.15799271238887527, "spearman": 0.3388209121245829 }, "mlp_entropy": { "pearson": -0.6355230712915908, "spearman": -0.6400444938820912 }, "mlp_latest": { "pearson": 0.6896916851820697, "spearman": 0.692992213570634 }, "mlp_max": { "pearson": 0.7022594570959072, "spearman": 0.7045606229143493 }, "points": 30 }, "target_layers": [ { "attention_entropy": 0.9286576240857585, "attention_latest": 0.34922462701797485, "attention_max": 0.34922462701797485, "group": 5, "layer": 19, "mlp_entropy": 0.8417470208868109, "mlp_latest": 0.4519178469975789, "mlp_max": 0.4519178469975789, "normalized_gradient": 1.0628893270643442, "offset": 3, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 0.6978155985835179, 1.1574347089891701, 1.3334176736203447 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.9460862283961503, "attention_latest": 0.3155268132686615, "attention_max": 0.3155268132686615, "group": 5, "layer": 20, "mlp_entropy": 0.862835637646716, "mlp_latest": 0.4188626905282338, "mlp_max": 0.4188626905282338, "normalized_gradient": 1.0135704098952112, "offset": 4, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 0.8168473226649812, 1.060138766241709, 1.1637251407789435 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.9687891325525921, "attention_latest": 0.2497197538614273, "attention_max": 0.2497197538614273, "group": 6, "layer": 21, "mlp_entropy": 0.7626460544111615, "mlp_latest": 0.512785017490387, "mlp_max": 0.512785017490387, "normalized_gradient": 3.0420861976019666, "offset": 1, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 3.219066994145898, 3.6189242296270336, 2.2882673690329693 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.8507401102456327, "attention_latest": 0.4364195068677266, "attention_max": 0.4364195068677266, "group": 6, "layer": 22, "mlp_entropy": 0.7208451982094757, "mlp_latest": 0.563143769900004, "mlp_max": 0.563143769900004, "normalized_gradient": 2.405186320789127, "offset": 2, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 2.5077095541323673, 2.81239769967395, 1.8954517085610634 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.879444880309749, "attention_latest": 0.40026357769966125, "attention_max": 0.40026357769966125, "group": 6, "layer": 23, "mlp_entropy": 0.7369153442658093, "mlp_latest": 0.5514553984006246, "mlp_max": 0.5514553984006246, "normalized_gradient": 1.9103037349623444, "offset": 3, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 1.973834673592298, 2.2018329150221976, 1.5552436162725376 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.8894285781602397, "attention_latest": 0.38436253865559894, "attention_max": 0.38436253865559894, "group": 6, "layer": 24, "mlp_entropy": 0.7713335619488723, "mlp_latest": 0.5146652460098267, "mlp_max": 0.5146652460098267, "normalized_gradient": 1.548088097624808, "offset": 4, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 1.5759251613516239, 1.7615672973682381, 1.306771834154562 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.9336027031788025, "attention_latest": 0.3171870708465576, "attention_max": 0.3171870708465576, "group": 7, "layer": 25, "mlp_entropy": 0.7657190825854533, "mlp_latest": 0.3575698534647624, "mlp_max": 0.3722212314605713, "normalized_gradient": 1.7685028111508305, "offset": 1, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 2.2647260999477155, 1.8179181698124194, 1.2228641636923565 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.8756262007907392, "attention_latest": 0.3432680070400238, "attention_max": 0.3432680070400238, "group": 7, "layer": 26, "mlp_entropy": 0.7635627832181188, "mlp_latest": 0.4196455279986064, "mlp_max": 0.4196455279986064, "normalized_gradient": 1.3690565893386435, "offset": 2, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 1.6880724220748888, 1.4871187506667403, 0.9319785952743014 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.891179394493967, "attention_latest": 0.32520759105682373, "attention_max": 0.32520759105682373, "group": 7, "layer": 27, "mlp_entropy": 0.7748494313187421, "mlp_latest": 0.40247613191604614, "mlp_max": 0.40247613191604614, "normalized_gradient": 0.9864745886014125, "offset": 3, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 1.092454232265147, 1.086854135909831, 0.7801153976292595 ] }, { "attention_entropy": 0.9019494449297653, "attention_latest": 0.2957511991262436, "attention_max": 0.2957511991262436, "group": 7, "layer": 28, "mlp_entropy": 0.821866239503451, "mlp_latest": 0.30352112650871277, "mlp_max": 0.3173763652642568, "normalized_gradient": 0.8024500092961132, "offset": 4, "per_seed_normalized_gradient": [ 0.8732751258075867, 0.872703317202576, 0.661371584878177 ] } ] }, "protocol_id": "llm-atlas-k3-attnres-spike-path-v1", "runs": [ { "canonical_sha256": "76b0ccfb55c38baef50c395788ac4b351cbe0d58de70064b50702acb5c93f515", "final_bpc": 1.7123525940760473, "final_model_state": "3f0b97ece3a15571ba3d656f589f512ca0bb9e20083c9f58a42ccaee14892f59", "final_optimizer_state": "ed03e6fbd4a12d8b063dcb22e0437754285f54d585374cd52fbd534f05d24637", "seed": 2026073001, "timing": { "mean_ms": 224.20719212223366, "measured_steps": 7980, "median_ms": 227.38306851533707, "p95_ms": 230.37451171875, "peak_allocated_bytes": 12841009152, "peak_reserved_bytes": 13922992128, "warmup_steps_excluded": 20 } }, { "canonical_sha256": "5352c74eca853b375c0e85933dafd7c5916c39fc59052e742ca14ffd6d68bc78", "final_bpc": 1.7093240655856785, "final_model_state": "bd2556388aeaa211b798c283c7cbd8ccd29edf166a2922fa13d172e8dfdc38d1", "final_optimizer_state": "0b101eab3bc7d8d654be2ea335c86fc25563ce19912d721844ee4e639c569e77", "seed": 2026073002, "timing": { "mean_ms": 223.82424076982844, "measured_steps": 7980, "median_ms": 227.36876149429008, "p95_ms": 229.48265075683594, "peak_allocated_bytes": 12841009152, "peak_reserved_bytes": 13922992128, "warmup_steps_excluded": 20 } }, { "canonical_sha256": "7e764c07e90b78c4cd0acc2e99600225f16428cbb25d5188a0a5a8fe797f8766", "final_bpc": 1.7030966812870931, "final_model_state": "638568aede21890773b6932a19ec4e112f5ac0a4770ba3402fcd82980a9ecf76", "final_optimizer_state": "83947fd743ec8e3e31ca7788fd201981846f0f1c7e9e38c88afcef95cfc6ec4e", "seed": 2026073003, "timing": { "mean_ms": 224.65581085475935, "measured_steps": 7980, "median_ms": 227.5267465010984, "p95_ms": 230.52696228027344, "peak_allocated_bytes": 12841009152, "peak_reserved_bytes": 13922992128, "warmup_steps_excluded": 20 } } ], "schema_version": 1, "study": { "architecture": "block", "depth": 32, "identity": "targeted follow-up informed by Round 05; not blind discovery", "seeds": [ 2026073001, 2026073002, 2026073003 ], "spike_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 ], "steps": 8000 }, "trajectory": [ { "points": [ { "bits_per_byte": 7.9557801867581395, "peak_layer": 1, "peak_normalized": 1.7717451736709768, "population_cv": 0.2714186609524326, "spike_contrast": 0.7816308178118705, "step": 0 }, { "bits_per_byte": 5.165135820292823, "peak_layer": 1, "peak_normalized": 2.145023601546889, "population_cv": 0.5072011380661324, "spike_contrast": 0.5596113913680666, "step": 100 }, { "bits_per_byte": 3.109974443324717, "peak_layer": 2, "peak_normalized": 2.1343785185339303, "population_cv": 0.5868596491376813, "spike_contrast": 0.5221542367874475, "step": 500 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.9592225965086283, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.863607509132394, "population_cv": 0.5384894543542103, "spike_contrast": 2.4966108002124767, "step": 2000 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.8027438806514628, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.115049509935762, "population_cv": 0.6027314599912318, "spike_contrast": 2.8510104941924466, "step": 4000 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.7123525940760473, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.219066994145898, "population_cv": 0.6420341358971389, "spike_contrast": 3.04626897714722, "step": 8000 } ], "seed": 2026073001 }, { "points": [ { "bits_per_byte": 8.034013546791773, "peak_layer": 1, "peak_normalized": 2.16920774571012, "population_cv": 0.39438035124793563, "spike_contrast": 0.6908033638721538, "step": 0 }, { "bits_per_byte": 5.132431212443787, "peak_layer": 1, "peak_normalized": 2.254829765809383, "population_cv": 0.5330470009230729, "spike_contrast": 0.5561530270868602, "step": 100 }, { "bits_per_byte": 3.0911456537212687, "peak_layer": 2, "peak_normalized": 2.173061151786652, "population_cv": 0.5858213540607353, "spike_contrast": 0.5734017265344913, "step": 500 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.947918907793682, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.189751492495938, "population_cv": 0.6175097196118516, "spike_contrast": 2.740373880872814, "step": 2000 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.7911587423283797, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.420348943656972, "population_cv": 0.6827037752697015, "spike_contrast": 3.1572107254761765, "step": 4000 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.7093240655856785, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6189242296270336, "population_cv": 0.7299683279122143, "spike_contrast": 3.3328477735441013, "step": 8000 } ], "seed": 2026073002 }, { "points": [ { "bits_per_byte": 8.061194200882085, "peak_layer": 1, "peak_normalized": 1.7301666786506156, "population_cv": 0.2498932502086342, "spike_contrast": 0.7974048446155259, "step": 0 }, { "bits_per_byte": 5.191908918496252, "peak_layer": 1, "peak_normalized": 2.133789250541258, "population_cv": 0.49221598973047537, "spike_contrast": 0.5746026267549044, "step": 100 }, { "bits_per_byte": 3.0881952483500545, "peak_layer": 2, "peak_normalized": 2.195594858531836, "population_cv": 0.606636113722199, "spike_contrast": 0.47779529155407807, "step": 500 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.948972795980338, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 1.8057756999530474, "population_cv": 0.34914284904214865, "spike_contrast": 1.4606649819879878, "step": 2000 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.7872753095784035, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.1130451955668876, "population_cv": 0.3859968358313239, "spike_contrast": 1.7734534826874866, "step": 4000 }, { "bits_per_byte": 1.7030966812870931, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2882673690329693, "population_cv": 0.42684708327825066, "spike_contrast": 1.8814916302334765, "step": 8000 } ], "seed": 2026073003 } ], "verdicts": { "interventions": { "forward_identity": [ { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073001 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073002 }, { "passed": true, "seed": 2026073003 } ], "scope": "all 64 depth mixers plus the output mixer", "softmax_key_path": { "label": "global removal of all mixer softmax/query/key source-gradient paths", "mean_relative_drop_contrast": -0.0200106813233286, "mean_relative_drop_peak": -0.008401901006156563, "opposite_direction_3_of_3": true, "passed_3_of_3": false, "per_seed": [ { "passed": false, "relative_drop_contrast": -0.015414390900329828, "relative_drop_peak": -0.006668985338663224, "seed": 2026073001, "source_peak_normalized": 3.219066994145898, "source_spike_contrast": 3.04626897714722, "target_peak_normalized": 3.2405349047340315, "target_spike_contrast": 3.093225357948515 }, { "passed": false, "relative_drop_contrast": -0.01929133294667749, "relative_drop_peak": -0.003788054520504258, "seed": 2026073002, "source_peak_normalized": 3.6189242296270336, "source_spike_contrast": 3.3328477735441013, "target_peak_normalized": 3.6326329119144347, "target_spike_contrast": 3.3971428496041334 }, { "passed": false, "relative_drop_contrast": -0.025326320122978477, "relative_drop_peak": -0.014748663159302204, "seed": 2026073003, "source_peak_normalized": 2.2882673690329693, "source_spike_contrast": 1.8814916302334765, "target_peak_normalized": 2.3220162536772593, "target_spike_contrast": 1.9291428895694742 } ], "same_direction_3_of_3": false, "source_mode": "learned", "target_mode": "detached_learned", "threshold": 0.2, "verdict": "opposite direction in 3/3 seeds; no material reduction" }, "value_coefficients": { "label": "global replacement of learned value-backward coefficients with 1/N", "mean_relative_drop_contrast": 0.701998806119879, "mean_relative_drop_peak": 0.3702754647109951, "opposite_direction_3_of_3": false, "passed_3_of_3": true, "per_seed": [ { "passed": true, "relative_drop_contrast": 0.7479318970064935, "relative_drop_peak": 0.3925047809741125, "seed": 2026073001, "source_peak_normalized": 3.2405349047340315, "source_spike_contrast": 3.093225357948515, "target_peak_normalized": 1.968609461712434, "target_spike_contrast": 0.7797034481094922 }, { "passed": true, "relative_drop_contrast": 0.7687299974719846, "relative_drop_peak": 0.4318458552099138, "seed": 2026073002, "source_peak_normalized": 3.6326329119144347, "source_spike_contrast": 3.3971428496041334, "target_peak_normalized": 2.063895445405066, "target_spike_contrast": 0.7856572354159773 }, { "passed": true, "relative_drop_contrast": 0.5893345238811586, "relative_drop_peak": 0.2864757579489588, "seed": 2026073003, "source_peak_normalized": 2.3220162536772593, "source_spike_contrast": 1.9291428895694742, "target_peak_normalized": 1.6568148874352646, "target_spike_contrast": 0.7922323832463255 } ], "same_direction_3_of_3": true, "source_mode": "detached_learned", "target_mode": "uniform_value_backward", "threshold": 0.2, "verdict": "material sensitivity at the preregistered threshold" } }, "reduction_robustness": { "cells": [ { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "element_rms", "seed": 2026073001, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 1.0, "spike_contrast": 3.04626897714722, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_mean", "seed": 2026073001, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9578445747800587, "spike_contrast": 2.869084843241085, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_median", "seed": 2026073001, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9013929618768328, "spike_contrast": 2.6456990159702416, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_p95", "seed": 2026073001, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9967008797653959, "spike_contrast": 3.143466990402101, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 25, 23, 26 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "element_rms", "seed": 2026073002, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 1.0, "spike_contrast": 3.3328477735441013, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_mean", "seed": 2026073002, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9732404692082112, "spike_contrast": 3.18249263251226, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_median", "seed": 2026073002, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.8951612903225806, "spike_contrast": 2.9052606637917697, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 4 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_p95", "seed": 2026073002, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9970674486803519, "spike_contrast": 3.5324549012779802, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 25, 24 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 5 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "element_rms", "seed": 2026073003, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 1.0, "spike_contrast": 1.8814916302334765, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 23, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_mean", "seed": 2026073003, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9875366568914956, "spike_contrast": 1.8077155175462722, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 18, 23 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_median", "seed": 2026073003, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9343841642228738, "spike_contrast": 1.6658967617763285, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 17, 18, 23 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 }, { "checks": { "spearman": true, "spike_contrast": true, "top_five_overlap": true }, "passed": true, "reduction": "token_rms_p95", "seed": 2026073003, "spearman_vs_element_rms": 0.9926686217008798, "spike_contrast": 2.0122799667677387, "top_five_layers": [ 21, 22, 23, 17, 18 ], "top_five_spike_overlap": 3 } ], "passed_cells": 12, "total_cells": 12, "verdict": "robust within the preregistered reduction family" }, "visible_positions": { "criterion": "step 8000 element-RMS spike contrast >= 1.5 in 3/3 seeds", "earliest_observed_tensor": "pre_attention_input", "positions": [ { "mean_spike_contrast": 2.9842437043760683, "per_seed": [ { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 4.232714993086349, "seed": 2026073001, "spike_contrast": 3.7241794809927478 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.51885122958336, "seed": 2026073002, "spike_contrast": 3.1885950432011234 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 2.5497535502321647, "seed": 2026073003, "spike_contrast": 2.0399565889343343 } ], "position": "pre_attention_input", "visible_3_of_3": true }, { "mean_spike_contrast": 2.9553267731281916, "per_seed": [ { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.138964807406113, "seed": 2026073001, "spike_contrast": 3.1996375366532934 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.7925106998539326, "seed": 2026073002, "spike_contrast": 3.6616605179769537 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2656295070514414, "seed": 2026073003, "spike_contrast": 2.004682264754327 } ], "position": "attention_branch_output", "visible_3_of_3": true }, { "mean_spike_contrast": 2.9553191807218897, "per_seed": [ { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.1389231589965445, "seed": 2026073001, "spike_contrast": 3.1996384204494492 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.7925041485004933, "seed": 2026073002, "spike_contrast": 3.6616533387138865 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.265619973525555, "seed": 2026073003, "spike_contrast": 2.0046657830023333 } ], "position": "post_attention_state", "visible_3_of_3": true }, { "mean_spike_contrast": 3.7778825845934967, "per_seed": [ { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 2.987231504916195, "seed": 2026073001, "spike_contrast": 3.828767846228416 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.828274701557073, "seed": 2026073002, "spike_contrast": 4.52698797699541 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 22, "peak_normalized": 2.526943137473127, "seed": 2026073003, "spike_contrast": 2.977891930556664 } ], "position": "pre_mlp_input", "visible_3_of_3": true }, { "mean_spike_contrast": 2.7535328779602537, "per_seed": [ { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.2190719364475022, "seed": 2026073001, "spike_contrast": 3.0462648281411457 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6189237818679025, "seed": 2026073002, "spike_contrast": 3.3328561680843984 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2882576030527964, "seed": 2026073003, "spike_contrast": 1.8814776376552176 } ], "position": "mlp_branch_output", "visible_3_of_3": true }, { "mean_spike_contrast": 2.7535361269749323, "per_seed": [ { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.219066994145898, "seed": 2026073001, "spike_contrast": 3.04626897714722 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 3.6189242296270336, "seed": 2026073002, "spike_contrast": 3.3328477735441013 }, { "passed": true, "peak_layer": 21, "peak_normalized": 2.2882673690329693, "seed": 2026073003, "spike_contrast": 1.8814916302334765 } ], "position": "post_mlp_state", "visible_3_of_3": true } ], "verdict": "visible at one or more positions", "visible_positions": [ "pre_attention_input", "attention_branch_output", "post_attention_state", "pre_mlp_input", "mlp_branch_output", "post_mlp_state" ] } } }